âšď¸ Skipped - page is already crawled
| Filter | Status | Condition | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| HTTP status | PASS | download_http_code = 200 | HTTP 200 |
| Age cutoff | PASS | download_stamp > now() - 6 MONTH | 0.1 months ago |
| History drop | PASS | isNull(history_drop_reason) | No drop reason |
| Spam/ban | PASS | fh_dont_index != 1 AND ml_spam_score = 0 | ml_spam_score=0 |
| Canonical | PASS | meta_canonical IS NULL OR = '' OR = src_unparsed | Not set |
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| URL | https://www.thebulwark.com/p/how-has-donald-trumps-mental-state-affected-his-presidency |
| Last Crawled | 2026-04-19 17:29:35 (1 day ago) |
| First Indexed | 2024-04-11 20:27:22 (2 years ago) |
| HTTP Status Code | 200 |
| Meta Title | How Has Donald Trumpâs Mental State Affected His Presidency? |
| Meta Description | What we knew about his psychology four years ago, and what we know today. |
| Meta Canonical | null |
| Boilerpipe Text | US President Donald Trump delivers remarks in front of the media in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington, DC on June 1, 2020. - US President Donald Trump was due to make a televised address to the nation on Monday after days of anti-racism protests against police brutality that have erupted into violence. The White House announced that the president would make remarks imminently after he has been criticized for not publicly addressing in the crisis in recent days. (Photo by Brendan Smialowski / AFP) (Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images)
It seems so clear now.
In June 2016âroughly seven weeks before Donald Trump formally received the Republican nomination for presidentâI wrote an extended essay in the
Huffington Post
assessing his behaviors. The title was self-explanatory: â
Too Sick to Lead: The Lethal Personality Disorder of Donald Trump
.â
By then, Trump had supplied us with overwhelming evidence of an ineradicable pathology which utterly disqualified him for the presidency. But few political observers wanted to touch such a volatile subject.
His party feared him. The media put him in their customary analytical boxes, parsing his every move as if he were something grander, yet more normal, than a mentally disordered demagogue bereft of principles and starved for adulation. And those mental health professionals who dared address the obvious were
chided by their peers
for psychoanalyzing a man they had never met.
But we
had
met himâceaselessly, for decades, and never more than in the year before June 2016, when cable news frequently broadcast his appearances in their entirety. His character disorder was klieg-lit; central to Trumpâs pathology was his uncontrollable need to flaunt it.
Most remarkable about his psychological illness is the utter consistency of his behaviors. My descriptions of his pathology, and how it would operate in office, are as applicable today as they were four years ago. Save for factual references specific to 2016, I need not change a word. This owes nothing to my special insight, and everything to Trumpâs inability to be anything other than what he was and always will be: a man far too disturbed to occupy the White House.
That he does underscores the core issue in 2020: Will a critical swath of voters, despite all weâve learned about his unfitness for the presidency, return this man to power?
No longer can we rationalize away his disabling instabilityânot for tax cuts, or judges, or ideology writ large. By deliberately averting their eyes from the incessant manifestations of his feral inner landscape, the GOP and much of the news media became complicit in his Electoral College victoryâand the damage he has inflicted on our democracy and society.
To capture Trumpâs singular abnormality, I opened my June 2016 article by describing a telling example from his past: his disturbingly bizarre and infantile practice of pretending to be someone else while calling a reporter to brag about his own romantic life. After describing an audiotape of Trumpâs pseudonymous 1991 phone call to
People
magazine boasting about his supposed romantic involvement with several ultra-famous womenâmade despite the fact that he was living with his future wife Marla MaplesâI pointed out that this behavior was not merely âself-aggrandizingâ but also âgratuitously cruel, heedless of all but self, reckless in his lust for attentionâ and, therefore, that it reflected on Trump's âpsychological fitness to be president.â
With this indubitably aberrant practice as preface, I argued that there is âonly one organizing principleâ that can make sense of Trumpâs âwildly oscillating utterances and behaviorâthe clinical definition of narcissistic personality disorder.â
The Mayo Clinic
describes it
as âa mental disorder in which people have an inflated sense of their own importance, a deep need for admiration and a lack of empathy for others.â This is bad enough in selecting a spouse or a friend. But when applied to a prospective president, the symptoms are disqualifying.
With Trump ever in mind, try these. An exaggerated sense of self-importance. An unwarranted belief in your own superiority. A preoccupation with fantasies of your own success, power and brilliance. A craving for constant admiration. A consuming sense of entitlement. An expectation of special favors and unquestioning compliance.
A penchant for exploiting or disparaging others. A total inability to recognize the needs of anyone else. An incapacity to see those you meet as separate human beings. An unreasoning fury at people you perceive as thwarting your wishes or desires. A tendency to act on impulse. A superficial charm deployed to disguise a gift for manipulation.
A need to always be right. A refusal to acknowledge error. An inability to tolerate criticism or critics. A compulsion to conform your everâshifting sense of ârealityâ to satisfy your inner requirements. A tendency to lie so frequently and routinely that objective truth loses all meaning.
A belief that you are above the rules. An array of inconsistent statements and behaviors driven by your needs in the moment. An inability to assess the consequences of your actions in new or complex situations. In sum, a total incapacity to separate the world from your own psychodrama.
Recognize anyone? . . .
The annals of business are filled with such people, some of whom wind up in jail, others of whom die rich. But however puissant they become in their chosen realm, their sickness of mind and spirit cannot ruin a country. That power is reserved for presidents.
Indeed, Trumpâs rise simply swells his unwarranted belief that he can stride the world like a colossusânaked of judgment, knowledge, temperament or preparation. This reflects a fatal deficit in those who suffer this disorderâthey cannot see themselves as they are.
To the contrary, their grandiosity is a defense against feelings of inadequacy too deep and painful to acknowledge. By the consensus of mental health experts, this emotional impairment has a last fatal ingredientâthere is no cure. For a man like Donald Trump, life offers no lessons, no path forward save to continue as you have until, like Icarus, you fly too close to the sun.
This disability involves far more than a set of discrete character flaws, however grave, including those which suggest a lack of trustworthiness. We survived the dishonesty and paranoia of Richard Nixon, after all, albeit at considerable cost and only after forcing him from office.
But in many ways Nixon was well-equipped for the presidency, capable of navigating the larger world and understanding complex situations and peopleâas in China and its leaders. He did not reflexively substitute a grossly inflated sense of self for knowledge, strategy or preparation. His tragedy, and ours, was that his crippling inner wounds outstripped his proven strengths.
Donald Trump is altogether differentâand infinitely more dangerous. He is afflicted with a comprehensive and profound character disorder which leaves no corner of his psyche whole. And this dictatesâand explainsâevery aspect of his behavior.
Take his recourse to bullying and slander. âIâm a counterpuncher,â he rationalizes. â[I]âve been responding to what they did to me.â Now we understand, Donaldâyour enemies made you do it.
Really? So Heidi Cruz made him ridicule her looks on Twitter? That handicapped reporter made him imitate his disabilities at a rally? . . . And on and onâthe list of enemies he must demean is infinite.
A recent example typifies his psychological imbalance. Speaking at a rally in San Diego, he tried to shame an otherwise obscure federal judge in the city, who is presiding over a lawsuit against Trump University. Trump called the Indiana-born judge a âMexican,â a âhater of Donald Trumpâ and a âvery hostile personâ who had ârailroadedâ him. Heedless of his position or his audience, Trump wallowed in his personal grievances so long that his listeners grew restive. And so, yet again, the campaign for president descended into the poisonous murk of Trumpâs inner world.
This astoundingly graceless and unpresidential behavior is far too pointless and indiscriminate to qualify as strategy or tactics. The common thread in all this lashing outâoften at those who canât fight backâis that it has nothing to do with issues, or anything else one would expect from a normal candidate. It is another symptom of Trumpâs pathologyâthe visceral reflex to humiliate and degrade anyone who displeases him, no matter the context or situation.
Take the media. Where, one might ask, would Trump be without its constant and credulous attentions? But, like everyone else, the media can never do enough to feed his needs. He threatens the owners of newspapers with reprisals by the federal government, talks of changing libel laws to facilitate lawsuits for statements which affront him, proposes revoking FCC licenses for media which ruffle him. CNN is âvery unprofessionalâ; like so many others, Fox has treated him âvery unfairly.â
He refers to the media which cover him as âscum.â He singles out by name reporters who dare to challenge him. . . . After all, Trump says, heâs âfighting for survivalââever victimized by hostile forces who fail to recognize his innate superiority.
Opposition of any kind enrages him. He incites reprisals against protesters. He threatened violence in Cleveland as payback for the GOPâs âunfairness.â He fuels anger against Hispanics, Muslims, and other minorities whom he perceives as inimical. And neverânot onceâdoes he take any responsibility for stirring these toxic pots. For one of the symptoms of his disability is an absence of conscience or accountability.
So what did women do to him, one wonders? The offense was obviously grave, for his misogyny is endless and, it seems, uncontrollable. One can but identify the same symptoms which drive his comprehensive impulse to demeanâthe need to dominate, displeasure at feeling thwarted and, of course, a profound lack of empathy for anyone but himself.
But for âTrump,â ever beset, his empathy is boundless. His view of others vacillates wildly based solely on their deferenceâor lack of it. . . .
Which brings us to a central problem of Trumpâs warped psychologyâhe believes that filling the presidency requires nothing but the wonder of himself. This gives the lie to GOPâs most craven rationalization of its own capitulation: that a suddenly docile Trump will, as president, defer to a cadre of wise and experienced advisers drawn from the party establishment.
This is pernicious nonsense. Consistent with his character disorder, Trump proudly insists that his chief adviser is himself. Even were he so inclined, in order to learn from others he must know enough to discern good advice from bad. But such is his pathology that he feels no need to learn much of anything from anyone. And so, from the beginning, he has plunged us down the bottomless rabbit hole of his intellectual emptiness.
His ignorance and grandiosity form a lethal compound. He disowns NATO, unaware that he is playing into Putinâs hands . . . and imagines negotiating one-on-one with North Koreaâs psychotic leader. . . . Oblivious to the appalled reaction around the globe, he promises to compel the respect of world leaders through âthe aura of personality.â
His equally spurious domestic âproposals,â such as they may be, reflect nothing but the unreality of his own self-concept. . .
But to talk of Trump in terms of issues is to flatter him. Most of what he says is provisional, ever subject to change, and based on nothing but his needs at the moment. . . .
One can forecast the inevitable day-to-day damage to our countryâthe lashings out, the abuses of power, the mercurial and confidence-destroying lies and changes of mind, the havoc his distorted lens would wreak upon our institutions and our spirit. But most dangerous of all is the collision between a volatile world, a leader unable to perceive external reality, and the often-unbearable pressures of the presidency. That Trumpâs judgment would crack time and again is certainâthe only question is how dangerous the moment.
So how have we fallen prey to a man who, by the damning evidence of his own behavior, is psychologically unfit to be president? When did boasting top coherence; mindless posturing become strength; a talent for ridicule supplant experience or judgement; a gift for scapegoating surpass wisdom or generosity? Why must we even contemplate someone with this stunted inner landscape as the worldâs most powerful man? Why, indeed? But that was thenâ2016. In 2020 Americaâs electorate has experienced three and a half years of the most aberrant presidency in our history. We have no excuses left.
Our presidentâs sickness is ever on display. According to the
Washington Post
, as of May 29 Trump had made
more than 19,000 false or misleading claims
in a little over 1,200 days in office. During this time, we have witnessed his manipulation of the Justice Department, attacks on the rule of law, refusal to honor congressional subpoenas, fascination with authoritarian leaders, assertions of unlimited power, and attempts to solicit or compel electoral assistance from foreign governments.
Hungry for attention, he subjects us to a constant stream of scurrilous tweets, false accusations, rank divisiveness, unhinged conspiracy theories, blatant racial innuendos, shameless denials of reality, reflexive self-pity, unbounded grandiosity, puerile insults to real or imagined enemies, and claims of superior expertise in a multitude of areas where his abysmal ignorance is manifest. His sole concern is for himself.
This confluence of anti-social behaviors would be shocking in a relative or coworker; in a president, they are frightening and disorienting. Since his inauguration, Trump has debased the coinage of the presidency, eroded the boundaries on presidential misconduct, and poisoned the well of civic decency. His crippling dysfunction is now ours.
These behaviors have caused an increasing number of mental health professional to issue warnings about Trumpâs psychological condition. In 2017, forensic psychiatrist Bandy X. Lee edited a book,
The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump
, that included essays from dozens of psychiatrists, psychologists, and mental health professionals. And last December, two weeks before Trumpâs impeachment, Dr. Lee
submitted to Congress a petition
, with 650 other psychiatrists, psychologists, and mental health professionals as co-signatories, which included this disturbing admonition:
What makes Donald Trump so dangerous is the brittleness of his sense of worth. Any slight or criticism is experienced as a humiliation and degradation. To cope with the resultant hollow and empty feeling, he reacts with what is referred to as narcissistic rage. He is unable to take responsibility for any error, mistake, or failing. His default in that situation is to blame others and to attack the perceived source of his humiliation. These attacks of narcissistic rage can be brutal and destructive.â
Further,
Lee explained to the London Independent
, Trump was âdoubling and . . . tripling down on his delusionsâ; âramping up his conspiracy theoriesâ; and âshowing a great deal of cruelty and vindictivenessâ in his âaccelerated, repetitive tweets.â
Recent examples include
his vicious allegations
that, twenty years ago, Joe Scarborough murdered a woman who worked in his Florida congressional office. In reality, she died of a heart attack when Scarborough was 500 miles away. But Trumpâs cruelty caused her anguished widower to implore Twitter to delete his sadistic tweets.
A related sign of emotional instability is Trumpâs obsession with projecting dominance and strengthâthe underside of which is a debilitating admixture of neediness and insecurity.
Recent examples abound. Some would be seriocomic were he not Americaâs president:
As reported by Ashley Parker and Josh Dawsey
in the
Washington Post
, Trump sidetracked a cabinet meeting with a lengthy re-enactment of his supposedly stellar performanceâthree years priorâon a cognitive screening test.
After taking refuge in an underground bunker when protesters ringed the White House, he furiously denied itâclaiming to have been conducting
a snap inspection tour
.
When a videotape captured his halting descent down a ramp after speaking at West Point, Trump delivered a rambling fifteen-minute revisionist history at his rally in Tulsaâblaming, among other things,
slippery shoes
.
Other examples are alarming, indeed ominous. His constant calls to âdominateâ the streets during protests following the death of George Floyd. His threats to deploy active duty troops on American soil. His misuse of military personnel to clear peaceful protesters near Lafayette Squareâall so that he could hold a borrowed Bible aloft in front of a damaged church, a videotaped piece of authoritarian theater.
The gnawing hunger of Trumpâs misshapen psyche dominates Carl Bernsteinâs appalling new account for CNN of the presidentâs conversations with foreign leaders, detailing in the starkest terms the consequences of investing someone of his pathology with the power of the American presidency.
Writes Bernstein
:
Trump was so consistently unprepared for discussion of serious issues, so often outplayed in his conversations with powerful leaders like . . . Vladimir Putin and Turkish president Recep ErdoÄan, and so abusive to leaders of Americaâs principal allies, that the calls helped convince some senior U.S. officialsâincluding his former secretaries of state and defense, two national security advisers and his longest-serving chief of staffâthat the president himself posed a danger to the national security of the United States . . . [and] to conclude that the president was often âdelusional,â as two sources put it, in his dealings with foreign leaders.
Central to these conversations was Trumpâs disabling absorption with himself: âTrump incessantly boasted to his fellow heads of state, including . . . North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un, about his own wealth, genius, âgreatâ accomplishments as president, and the âidiocyâ of his Oval Office predecessors. . . . In his phone exchanges with Putin . . . the president talked mostly about himself . . . [while] obsequiously courting Putinâs admiration and approval.â Adds Bernstein: âThe common, overwhelming dynamic that characterizes Trumpâs conversations with both authoritarian dictators and leaders of the worldâs greatest democracies is his consistent assertion of himself as the defining subject and subtext of the calls.â
But for allies, Trumpâs manner was the opposite of his pandering to the authoritarians: bullying, abusive, and riven with grievances. âEverything was always personalized,â a source told Bernstein, âwith everybody doing terrible things to rip us offâwhich meant ripping âmeââTrumpâoff.â With females, Trump added a withering misogyny. âHis most vicious attacks,â Bernstein relates, âwere aimed at women heads of state. In conversations with both [Theresa] May and [Angela] Merkel, the president demeaned and denigrated them in diatribes described as ânear-sadistic.ââ
Other consistent features of these phone calls were Trumpâs ignorance and dissociation from reality. âTwo sources,â Bernstein reports, âcompared many of the presidentâs conversations with foreign leaders to Trumpâs recent press âbriefingsâ on the coronavirus pandemic: free form, fact-deficient stream-of-consciousness ramblings, full of fantasy and off-the-wall pronouncements based on his intuitions, guesswork, the opinions of Fox News TV hosts and social media misinformation.â
Bernstein concludes by quoting a senior official who summarizes the grip of Trumpâs personality disorder on his conduct of foreign affairs: âThere was no sense of âTeam Americaâ or of . . . certain democratic principles and leadership of the free world. . . . The opposite. It was like the United States had disappeared. It was always âJust me.ââ
But, for now, all else is overshadowed by Trumpâs catastrophic mishandling of COVID-19âa case study in the literally lethal consequences of his hydra-headed disorder. This is precisely what I meant when, in 2016, I wrote about the dangerous collision between âvolatile world, a leader unable to perceive external reality, and the often
-
unbearable pressures of the presidency.â Trump need not precipitate a nuclear exchange for his warped psychology to cause tens of thousands of needless American deaths.
It has. Last month disease modelers at Columbia
estimated
that we would have incurred roughly 36,000 fewer fatalities had Trump initiated social distancing one week earlier, and 54,000 deaths had it started two weeks earlier. Instead, fearful that acknowledging the seriousness of the coronavirus would have adverse political consequences, Trump chose misleading the public over protecting lives.
Inexorably, the deadly pandemic overwhelmed Trumpâs self-created alternate realityâin which denying its lethality substituted for action. So he substituted yet another fantasy: that his proactive leadership in fighting the virus had saved countless lives and defeated the pandemic.
Even as the death toll mounted, he urged state governments to reopen the economyâdismissing life-saving public health measures recommended by his own government. COVID-19,
he told Sean Hannity
, is âfading away.â A week later, we suffered the
greatest number of new cases since the pandemic began
.
Events in the real world provide a roadmap of Trumpâs delusions. The coronavirus spiked in the states that were the swiftest to reopen. The European Union has
banned Americans
as threats to public health. Contradicting Trump,
Anthony Fauci warned Congress
that âthe virus is not going to disappear,â adding that âwe are still in the middle of a serious outbreak.â
No matter to Trump. In his imaginary America, the real problem became that we were testing too much, thereby increasing the count of new cases.
By then, as his pathology dictates, Trump had put blame for the pandemic on China, the World Health Organization, the media, Barack Obama, the intelligence community, and the CDC. And he had discovered the real victim of COVID-19: himself. In
Vanity Fair
, Gabriel Sherman
reported Trump telling a confidant
: âThis is so unfair to me! Everything was going great. We were cruising to reelection!â
Instead, the pandemic has underscored Trumpâs complete indifference to other human beings. And not just the vulnerable, the sick, and the dead. He insisted that West Point graduates return to hear his commencement speech in the middle of a pandemic. He scheduled large indoor rallies in Tulsa and Phoenix, surefire super-spreaders, so that he could bask in adoring crowds.
When public health officials in Charlotte inquired about health measures for the GOP convention, Trump moved it to Jacksonvilleâsimply to ensure himself a jam-packed arena filled with unmasked faces, risk be damned. Over a three-week period of public statements amid the pandemic back in April,
the
Washington Post
reported
, Trump spoke for some thirteen hoursâof which he spent two hours attacking others, forty-five minutes praising himself and his administration, but just four-and-a-half minutes expressing rote sympathy for coronavirus victims and front-line workers.
Further, the
Post
related in late May
, âThe coronavirus pandemic has spawned a whole new genre of Trumpâs falsehoods. The category in just a few months has reached 800 claims, with his advocacy for hydroxychloroquine as a possible cure, based on minimal and flimsy evidence, already reaching Bottomless Pinocchio status.â As Trumpâs confidant told Sherman: âHe lives in his own fucking world.â
In that world, Trump is free from the constraints of constitutional democracy.
To stave off defeat, he and his party are striving to prevent the universal voting by mail necessitated by the pandemic, while groundlessly asserting that the mail-in balloting currently available guarantees massive voter fraud by the Democratic Party. Already,
Trump is claiming
that the 2020 election âwill be, in my opinion, the most corrupt election in the history of our country, and we cannot let this happen.â
This is insane. But an increasingly serious body of opinion anticipates that Trump will try to maintain power by denying the legitimacy of the November election. This captures how completely Trumpâs sickness has consumed usâexpecting our president to subvert American democracy is becoming our new normal.
The problem of Trump transcends party or ideology, and so does our need to be rid of him. For there is no constitutional guarantee against a president too mentally ill to respect its termsâand a party too craven to stop him.
Until further notice, we have both. |
| Markdown | [](https://www.thebulwark.com/)
# [](https://www.thebulwark.com/)
Join
Sign in
[Home](https://www.thebulwark.com/)
[Watch](https://www.thebulwark.com/watch)
[Shows](https://www.thebulwark.com/listen)
[Newsletters]()
[Chat](https://www.thebulwark.com/chat)
[Special Projects](https://specialto.thebulwark.com/)
[Events](https://www.thebulwark.com/p/bulwark-events)
[Founders](https://www.thebulwark.com/p/founding-members-hub)
[Store](https://thebulwark.myshopify.com/)
[Archive](https://www.thebulwark.com/archive)
[About](https://www.thebulwark.com/about)
# How Has Donald Trumpâs Mental State Affected His Presidency?
### What we knew about his psychology four years ago, and what we know today.
[](https://substack.com/@richardnorthpatterson)
[Richard North Patterson](https://substack.com/@richardnorthpatterson)
Jul 01, 2020
Share
[](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!z6fC!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fccec6619-2672-40c9-8182-5d4dab958191_3000x1999.jpeg)
US President Donald Trump delivers remarks in front of the media in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington, DC on June 1, 2020. - US President Donald Trump was due to make a televised address to the nation on Monday after days of anti-racism protests against police brutality that have erupted into violence. The White House announced that the president would make remarks imminently after he has been criticized for not publicly addressing in the crisis in recent days. (Photo by Brendan Smialowski / AFP) (Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images)
It seems so clear now.
In June 2016âroughly seven weeks before Donald Trump formally received the Republican nomination for presidentâI wrote an extended essay in the *Huffington Post* assessing his behaviors. The title was self-explanatory: â[Too Sick to Lead: The Lethal Personality Disorder of Donald Trump](https://www.huffpost.com/entry/too-sick-to-lead-the-leth_b_10086768).â
By then, Trump had supplied us with overwhelming evidence of an ineradicable pathology which utterly disqualified him for the presidency. But few political observers wanted to touch such a volatile subject.
His party feared him. The media put him in their customary analytical boxes, parsing his every move as if he were something grander, yet more normal, than a mentally disordered demagogue bereft of principles and starved for adulation. And those mental health professionals who dared address the obvious were [chided by their peers](https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/16/health/analyzing-donald-trump-psychology.html) for psychoanalyzing a man they had never met.
But we *had* met himâceaselessly, for decades, and never more than in the year before June 2016, when cable news frequently broadcast his appearances in their entirety. His character disorder was klieg-lit; central to Trumpâs pathology was his uncontrollable need to flaunt it.
***
Most remarkable about his psychological illness is the utter consistency of his behaviors. My descriptions of his pathology, and how it would operate in office, are as applicable today as they were four years ago. Save for factual references specific to 2016, I need not change a word. This owes nothing to my special insight, and everything to Trumpâs inability to be anything other than what he was and always will be: a man far too disturbed to occupy the White House.
That he does underscores the core issue in 2020: Will a critical swath of voters, despite all weâve learned about his unfitness for the presidency, return this man to power?
No longer can we rationalize away his disabling instabilityânot for tax cuts, or judges, or ideology writ large. By deliberately averting their eyes from the incessant manifestations of his feral inner landscape, the GOP and much of the news media became complicit in his Electoral College victoryâand the damage he has inflicted on our democracy and society.
***
To capture Trumpâs singular abnormality, I opened my June 2016 article by describing a telling example from his past: his disturbingly bizarre and infantile practice of pretending to be someone else while calling a reporter to brag about his own romantic life. After describing an audiotape of Trumpâs pseudonymous 1991 phone call to *People* magazine boasting about his supposed romantic involvement with several ultra-famous womenâmade despite the fact that he was living with his future wife Marla MaplesâI pointed out that this behavior was not merely âself-aggrandizingâ but also âgratuitously cruel, heedless of all but self, reckless in his lust for attentionâ and, therefore, that it reflected on Trump's âpsychological fitness to be president.â
With this indubitably aberrant practice as preface, I argued that there is âonly one organizing principleâ that can make sense of Trumpâs âwildly oscillating utterances and behaviorâthe clinical definition of narcissistic personality disorder.â
> The Mayo Clinic [describes it](https://web.archive.org/web/20160523013955/http:/www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/narcissistic-personality-disorder/basics/definition/con-20025568) as âa mental disorder in which people have an inflated sense of their own importance, a deep need for admiration and a lack of empathy for others.â This is bad enough in selecting a spouse or a friend. But when applied to a prospective president, the symptoms are disqualifying.
With Trump ever in mind, try these. An exaggerated sense of self-importance. An unwarranted belief in your own superiority. A preoccupation with fantasies of your own success, power and brilliance. A craving for constant admiration. A consuming sense of entitlement. An expectation of special favors and unquestioning compliance.
A penchant for exploiting or disparaging others. A total inability to recognize the needs of anyone else. An incapacity to see those you meet as separate human beings. An unreasoning fury at people you perceive as thwarting your wishes or desires. A tendency to act on impulse. A superficial charm deployed to disguise a gift for manipulation.
A need to always be right. A refusal to acknowledge error. An inability to tolerate criticism or critics. A compulsion to conform your everâshifting sense of ârealityâ to satisfy your inner requirements. A tendency to lie so frequently and routinely that objective truth loses all meaning.
A belief that you are above the rules. An array of inconsistent statements and behaviors driven by your needs in the moment. An inability to assess the consequences of your actions in new or complex situations. In sum, a total incapacity to separate the world from your own psychodrama.
Recognize anyone? . . .
The annals of business are filled with such people, some of whom wind up in jail, others of whom die rich. But however puissant they become in their chosen realm, their sickness of mind and spirit cannot ruin a country. That power is reserved for presidents.
Indeed, Trumpâs rise simply swells his unwarranted belief that he can stride the world like a colossusânaked of judgment, knowledge, temperament or preparation. This reflects a fatal deficit in those who suffer this disorderâthey cannot see themselves as they are.
To the contrary, their grandiosity is a defense against feelings of inadequacy too deep and painful to acknowledge. By the consensus of mental health experts, this emotional impairment has a last fatal ingredientâthere is no cure. For a man like Donald Trump, life offers no lessons, no path forward save to continue as you have until, like Icarus, you fly too close to the sun.
This disability involves far more than a set of discrete character flaws, however grave, including those which suggest a lack of trustworthiness. We survived the dishonesty and paranoia of Richard Nixon, after all, albeit at considerable cost and only after forcing him from office.
But in many ways Nixon was well-equipped for the presidency, capable of navigating the larger world and understanding complex situations and peopleâas in China and its leaders. He did not reflexively substitute a grossly inflated sense of self for knowledge, strategy or preparation. His tragedy, and ours, was that his crippling inner wounds outstripped his proven strengths.
Donald Trump is altogether differentâand infinitely more dangerous. He is afflicted with a comprehensive and profound character disorder which leaves no corner of his psyche whole. And this dictatesâand explainsâevery aspect of his behavior.
Take his recourse to bullying and slander. âIâm a counterpuncher,â he rationalizes. â\[I\]âve been responding to what they did to me.â Now we understand, Donaldâyour enemies made you do it.
Really? So Heidi Cruz made him ridicule her looks on Twitter? That handicapped reporter made him imitate his disabilities at a rally? . . . And on and onâthe list of enemies he must demean is infinite.
A recent example typifies his psychological imbalance. Speaking at a rally in San Diego, he tried to shame an otherwise obscure federal judge in the city, who is presiding over a lawsuit against Trump University. Trump called the Indiana-born judge a âMexican,â a âhater of Donald Trumpâ and a âvery hostile personâ who had ârailroadedâ him. Heedless of his position or his audience, Trump wallowed in his personal grievances so long that his listeners grew restive. And so, yet again, the campaign for president descended into the poisonous murk of Trumpâs inner world.
This astoundingly graceless and unpresidential behavior is far too pointless and indiscriminate to qualify as strategy or tactics. The common thread in all this lashing outâoften at those who canât fight backâis that it has nothing to do with issues, or anything else one would expect from a normal candidate. It is another symptom of Trumpâs pathologyâthe visceral reflex to humiliate and degrade anyone who displeases him, no matter the context or situation.
Take the media. Where, one might ask, would Trump be without its constant and credulous attentions? But, like everyone else, the media can never do enough to feed his needs. He threatens the owners of newspapers with reprisals by the federal government, talks of changing libel laws to facilitate lawsuits for statements which affront him, proposes revoking FCC licenses for media which ruffle him. CNN is âvery unprofessionalâ; like so many others, Fox has treated him âvery unfairly.â
He refers to the media which cover him as âscum.â He singles out by name reporters who dare to challenge him. . . . After all, Trump says, heâs âfighting for survivalââever victimized by hostile forces who fail to recognize his innate superiority.
Opposition of any kind enrages him. He incites reprisals against protesters. He threatened violence in Cleveland as payback for the GOPâs âunfairness.â He fuels anger against Hispanics, Muslims, and other minorities whom he perceives as inimical. And neverânot onceâdoes he take any responsibility for stirring these toxic pots. For one of the symptoms of his disability is an absence of conscience or accountability.
So what did women do to him, one wonders? The offense was obviously grave, for his misogyny is endless and, it seems, uncontrollable. One can but identify the same symptoms which drive his comprehensive impulse to demeanâthe need to dominate, displeasure at feeling thwarted and, of course, a profound lack of empathy for anyone but himself.
But for âTrump,â ever beset, his empathy is boundless. His view of others vacillates wildly based solely on their deferenceâor lack of it. . . .
Which brings us to a central problem of Trumpâs warped psychologyâhe believes that filling the presidency requires nothing but the wonder of himself. This gives the lie to GOPâs most craven rationalization of its own capitulation: that a suddenly docile Trump will, as president, defer to a cadre of wise and experienced advisers drawn from the party establishment.
This is pernicious nonsense. Consistent with his character disorder, Trump proudly insists that his chief adviser is himself. Even were he so inclined, in order to learn from others he must know enough to discern good advice from bad. But such is his pathology that he feels no need to learn much of anything from anyone. And so, from the beginning, he has plunged us down the bottomless rabbit hole of his intellectual emptiness.
His ignorance and grandiosity form a lethal compound. He disowns NATO, unaware that he is playing into Putinâs hands . . . and imagines negotiating one-on-one with North Koreaâs psychotic leader. . . . Oblivious to the appalled reaction around the globe, he promises to compel the respect of world leaders through âthe aura of personality.â
His equally spurious domestic âproposals,â such as they may be, reflect nothing but the unreality of his own self-concept. . .
But to talk of Trump in terms of issues is to flatter him. Most of what he says is provisional, ever subject to change, and based on nothing but his needs at the moment. . . .
One can forecast the inevitable day-to-day damage to our countryâthe lashings out, the abuses of power, the mercurial and confidence-destroying lies and changes of mind, the havoc his distorted lens would wreak upon our institutions and our spirit. But most dangerous of all is the collision between a volatile world, a leader unable to perceive external reality, and the often-unbearable pressures of the presidency. That Trumpâs judgment would crack time and again is certainâthe only question is how dangerous the moment.
So how have we fallen prey to a man who, by the damning evidence of his own behavior, is psychologically unfit to be president? When did boasting top coherence; mindless posturing become strength; a talent for ridicule supplant experience or judgement; a gift for scapegoating surpass wisdom or generosity? Why must we even contemplate someone with this stunted inner landscape as the worldâs most powerful man? Why, indeed? But that was thenâ2016. In 2020 Americaâs electorate has experienced three and a half years of the most aberrant presidency in our history. We have no excuses left.
Our presidentâs sickness is ever on display. According to the *Washington Post*, as of May 29 Trump had made [more than 19,000 false or misleading claims](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/01/president-trump-made-19127-false-or-misleading-claims-1226-days/) in a little over 1,200 days in office. During this time, we have witnessed his manipulation of the Justice Department, attacks on the rule of law, refusal to honor congressional subpoenas, fascination with authoritarian leaders, assertions of unlimited power, and attempts to solicit or compel electoral assistance from foreign governments.
Hungry for attention, he subjects us to a constant stream of scurrilous tweets, false accusations, rank divisiveness, unhinged conspiracy theories, blatant racial innuendos, shameless denials of reality, reflexive self-pity, unbounded grandiosity, puerile insults to real or imagined enemies, and claims of superior expertise in a multitude of areas where his abysmal ignorance is manifest. His sole concern is for himself.
This confluence of anti-social behaviors would be shocking in a relative or coworker; in a president, they are frightening and disorienting. Since his inauguration, Trump has debased the coinage of the presidency, eroded the boundaries on presidential misconduct, and poisoned the well of civic decency. His crippling dysfunction is now ours.
***
These behaviors have caused an increasing number of mental health professional to issue warnings about Trumpâs psychological condition. In 2017, forensic psychiatrist Bandy X. Lee edited a book, *[The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump](https://www.amazon.com/gp/B07NL1NHCR/)*, that included essays from dozens of psychiatrists, psychologists, and mental health professionals. And last December, two weeks before Trumpâs impeachment, Dr. Lee [submitted to Congress a petition](https://web.archive.org/web/20191209193923/https:/dangerouscase.org/petition-to-the-judiciary-committee/), with 650 other psychiatrists, psychologists, and mental health professionals as co-signatories, which included this disturbing admonition:
> What makes Donald Trump so dangerous is the brittleness of his sense of worth. Any slight or criticism is experienced as a humiliation and degradation. To cope with the resultant hollow and empty feeling, he reacts with what is referred to as narcissistic rage. He is unable to take responsibility for any error, mistake, or failing. His default in that situation is to blame others and to attack the perceived source of his humiliation. These attacks of narcissistic rage can be brutal and destructive.â
Further, [Lee explained to the London Independent](https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/trump-mental-state-impeachment-psychiatrist-petition-congress-a9232386.html), Trump was âdoubling and . . . tripling down on his delusionsâ; âramping up his conspiracy theoriesâ; and âshowing a great deal of cruelty and vindictivenessâ in his âaccelerated, repetitive tweets.â
Recent examples include [his vicious allegations](https://www.politico.com/news/2020/05/12/trump-conspiracy-theory-msnbc-251108) that, twenty years ago, Joe Scarborough murdered a woman who worked in his Florida congressional office. In reality, she died of a heart attack when Scarborough was 500 miles away. But Trumpâs cruelty caused her anguished widower to implore Twitter to delete his sadistic tweets.
A related sign of emotional instability is Trumpâs obsession with projecting dominance and strengthâthe underside of which is a debilitating admixture of neediness and insecurity.
Recent examples abound. Some would be seriocomic were he not Americaâs president:
- As reported by Ashley Parker and Josh Dawsey [in the](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-increasingly-preoccupied-with-defending-his-physical-and-mental-health/2020/06/22/c7e0a95c-b3ed-11ea-9b0f-c797548c1154_story.html) *[Washington Post](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-increasingly-preoccupied-with-defending-his-physical-and-mental-health/2020/06/22/c7e0a95c-b3ed-11ea-9b0f-c797548c1154_story.html)*, Trump sidetracked a cabinet meeting with a lengthy re-enactment of his supposedly stellar performanceâthree years priorâon a cognitive screening test.
- After taking refuge in an underground bunker when protesters ringed the White House, he furiously denied itâclaiming to have been conducting [a snap inspection tour](https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/06/donald-trump-denies-hiding-bunker-during-protests).
- When a videotape captured his halting descent down a ramp after speaking at West Point, Trump delivered a rambling fifteen-minute revisionist history at his rally in Tulsaâblaming, among other things, [slippery shoes](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-increasingly-preoccupied-with-defending-his-physical-and-mental-health/2020/06/22/c7e0a95c-b3ed-11ea-9b0f-c797548c1154_story.html).
Other examples are alarming, indeed ominous. His constant calls to âdominateâ the streets during protests following the death of George Floyd. His threats to deploy active duty troops on American soil. His misuse of military personnel to clear peaceful protesters near Lafayette Squareâall so that he could hold a borrowed Bible aloft in front of a damaged church, a videotaped piece of authoritarian theater.
***
The gnawing hunger of Trumpâs misshapen psyche dominates Carl Bernsteinâs appalling new account for CNN of the presidentâs conversations with foreign leaders, detailing in the starkest terms the consequences of investing someone of his pathology with the power of the American presidency.
[Writes Bernstein](https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/29/politics/trump-phone-calls-national-security-concerns/index.html):
> Trump was so consistently unprepared for discussion of serious issues, so often outplayed in his conversations with powerful leaders like . . . Vladimir Putin and Turkish president Recep ErdoÄan, and so abusive to leaders of Americaâs principal allies, that the calls helped convince some senior U.S. officialsâincluding his former secretaries of state and defense, two national security advisers and his longest-serving chief of staffâthat the president himself posed a danger to the national security of the United States . . . \[and\] to conclude that the president was often âdelusional,â as two sources put it, in his dealings with foreign leaders.
Central to these conversations was Trumpâs disabling absorption with himself: âTrump incessantly boasted to his fellow heads of state, including . . . North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un, about his own wealth, genius, âgreatâ accomplishments as president, and the âidiocyâ of his Oval Office predecessors. . . . In his phone exchanges with Putin . . . the president talked mostly about himself . . . \[while\] obsequiously courting Putinâs admiration and approval.â Adds Bernstein: âThe common, overwhelming dynamic that characterizes Trumpâs conversations with both authoritarian dictators and leaders of the worldâs greatest democracies is his consistent assertion of himself as the defining subject and subtext of the calls.â
But for allies, Trumpâs manner was the opposite of his pandering to the authoritarians: bullying, abusive, and riven with grievances. âEverything was always personalized,â a source told Bernstein, âwith everybody doing terrible things to rip us offâwhich meant ripping âmeââTrumpâoff.â With females, Trump added a withering misogyny. âHis most vicious attacks,â Bernstein relates, âwere aimed at women heads of state. In conversations with both \[Theresa\] May and \[Angela\] Merkel, the president demeaned and denigrated them in diatribes described as ânear-sadistic.ââ
Other consistent features of these phone calls were Trumpâs ignorance and dissociation from reality. âTwo sources,â Bernstein reports, âcompared many of the presidentâs conversations with foreign leaders to Trumpâs recent press âbriefingsâ on the coronavirus pandemic: free form, fact-deficient stream-of-consciousness ramblings, full of fantasy and off-the-wall pronouncements based on his intuitions, guesswork, the opinions of Fox News TV hosts and social media misinformation.â
Bernstein concludes by quoting a senior official who summarizes the grip of Trumpâs personality disorder on his conduct of foreign affairs: âThere was no sense of âTeam Americaâ or of . . . certain democratic principles and leadership of the free world. . . . The opposite. It was like the United States had disappeared. It was always âJust me.ââ
***
But, for now, all else is overshadowed by Trumpâs catastrophic mishandling of COVID-19âa case study in the literally lethal consequences of his hydra-headed disorder. This is precisely what I meant when, in 2016, I wrote about the dangerous collision between âvolatile world, a leader unable to perceive external reality, and the often**\-**unbearable pressures of the presidency.â Trump need not precipitate a nuclear exchange for his warped psychology to cause tens of thousands of needless American deaths.
It has. Last month disease modelers at Columbia [estimated](https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/20/us/coronavirus-distancing-deaths.html) that we would have incurred roughly 36,000 fewer fatalities had Trump initiated social distancing one week earlier, and 54,000 deaths had it started two weeks earlier. Instead, fearful that acknowledging the seriousness of the coronavirus would have adverse political consequences, Trump chose misleading the public over protecting lives.
Inexorably, the deadly pandemic overwhelmed Trumpâs self-created alternate realityâin which denying its lethality substituted for action. So he substituted yet another fantasy: that his proactive leadership in fighting the virus had saved countless lives and defeated the pandemic.
Even as the death toll mounted, he urged state governments to reopen the economyâdismissing life-saving public health measures recommended by his own government. COVID-19, [he told Sean Hannity](https://www.foxnews.com/media/trump-hannity-coronavirus-fading-away-tulsa-rally), is âfading away.â A week later, we suffered the [greatest number of new cases since the pandemic began](https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/us/coronavirus-us-cases.html).
Events in the real world provide a roadmap of Trumpâs delusions. The coronavirus spiked in the states that were the swiftest to reopen. The European Union has [banned Americans](https://www.nytimes.com/article/eu-travel-ban-explained-usa.html) as threats to public health. Contradicting Trump, [Anthony Fauci warned Congress](https://www.c-span.org/video/?473229-1/white-house-coronavirus-task-force-members-testify-federal-response-pandemic) that âthe virus is not going to disappear,â adding that âwe are still in the middle of a serious outbreak.â
No matter to Trump. In his imaginary America, the real problem became that we were testing too much, thereby increasing the count of new cases.
By then, as his pathology dictates, Trump had put blame for the pandemic on China, the World Health Organization, the media, Barack Obama, the intelligence community, and the CDC. And he had discovered the real victim of COVID-19: himself. In *Vanity Fair*, Gabriel Sherman [reported Trump telling a confidant](https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/05/trump-whines-about-his-covid-19-victimhood-as-campaign-flails): âThis is so unfair to me! Everything was going great. We were cruising to reelection!â
Instead, the pandemic has underscored Trumpâs complete indifference to other human beings. And not just the vulnerable, the sick, and the dead. He insisted that West Point graduates return to hear his commencement speech in the middle of a pandemic. He scheduled large indoor rallies in Tulsa and Phoenix, surefire super-spreaders, so that he could bask in adoring crowds.
When public health officials in Charlotte inquired about health measures for the GOP convention, Trump moved it to Jacksonvilleâsimply to ensure himself a jam-packed arena filled with unmasked faces, risk be damned. Over a three-week period of public statements amid the pandemic back in April, [the](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/13-hours-of-trump-the-president-fills-briefings-with-attacks-and-boasts-but-little-empathy/2020/04/25/7eec5ab0-8590-11ea-a3eb-e9fc93160703_story.html) *[Washington Post](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/13-hours-of-trump-the-president-fills-briefings-with-attacks-and-boasts-but-little-empathy/2020/04/25/7eec5ab0-8590-11ea-a3eb-e9fc93160703_story.html)* [reported](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/13-hours-of-trump-the-president-fills-briefings-with-attacks-and-boasts-but-little-empathy/2020/04/25/7eec5ab0-8590-11ea-a3eb-e9fc93160703_story.html), Trump spoke for some thirteen hoursâof which he spent two hours attacking others, forty-five minutes praising himself and his administration, but just four-and-a-half minutes expressing rote sympathy for coronavirus victims and front-line workers.
Further, the *[Post](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/01/president-trump-made-19127-false-or-misleading-claims-1226-days/)* [related in late May](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/01/president-trump-made-19127-false-or-misleading-claims-1226-days/), âThe coronavirus pandemic has spawned a whole new genre of Trumpâs falsehoods. The category in just a few months has reached 800 claims, with his advocacy for hydroxychloroquine as a possible cure, based on minimal and flimsy evidence, already reaching Bottomless Pinocchio status.â As Trumpâs confidant told Sherman: âHe lives in his own fucking world.â
In that world, Trump is free from the constraints of constitutional democracy.
***
To stave off defeat, he and his party are striving to prevent the universal voting by mail necessitated by the pandemic, while groundlessly asserting that the mail-in balloting currently available guarantees massive voter fraud by the Democratic Party. Already, [Trump is claiming](https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2020/06/24/trump_this_will_be_most_corrupt_election_in_the_history_of_our_country.html) that the 2020 election âwill be, in my opinion, the most corrupt election in the history of our country, and we cannot let this happen.â
This is insane. But an increasingly serious body of opinion anticipates that Trump will try to maintain power by denying the legitimacy of the November election. This captures how completely Trumpâs sickness has consumed usâexpecting our president to subvert American democracy is becoming our new normal.
The problem of Trump transcends party or ideology, and so does our need to be rid of him. For there is no constitutional guarantee against a president too mentally ill to respect its termsâand a party too craven to stop him.
Until further notice, we have both.
***
#### Subscribe to The Bulwark
Hundreds of thousands of paid subscribers
The Bulwark is home to Sarah Longwell, Tim Miller, Bill Kristol, JVL, Sam Stein, and more. We are the largest pro-democracy bundle on Substack for news and analysis on politics and cultureâsupported by a community built on good-faith.
By subscribing, you agree Substack's [Terms of Use](https://substack.com/tos), and acknowledge its [Information Collection Notice](https://substack.com/ccpa#personal-data-collected) and [Privacy Policy](https://substack.com/privacy).
Share
Previous
Next
| | |
|---|---|
| [](https://substack.com/@richardnorthpatterson?utm_source=byline) | |
| | |
| [Richard North Patterson](https://substack.com/@richardnorthpatterson?utm_campaign=guest_post_bio&utm_medium=web)RICHARD NORTH PATTERSON-author of The Spire, Eclipse & other bestselling novels. Former trial lawyer, he was SEC liaison to Watergate special prosecutor & has served on boardsj in of Washington advocacy groups. | [Subscribe to Richard](https://richardnorthpatterson.substack.com/subscribe) |
Top
Latest
Discussions
[The American Age Is Over](https://www.thebulwark.com/p/the-american-age-is-over)
[Emergency Triad: The United States commits imperial suicide.](https://www.thebulwark.com/p/the-american-age-is-over)
Apr 3, 2025
⢠[Jonathan V. Last](https://substack.com/@jvlast)
5,640
1,520
1,285
[How to Think (and Act) Like a Dissident Movement](https://www.thebulwark.com/p/how-to-think-and-act-like-a-dissident-in-trumps-america)
[AOC, solidarity, and people power.](https://www.thebulwark.com/p/how-to-think-and-act-like-a-dissident-in-trumps-america)
Mar 24, 2025
⢠[Jonathan V. Last](https://substack.com/@jvlast)
4,261
1,205
1,174
[Trump is Crashing Out And We're Loving It](https://www.thebulwark.com/p/trump-is-crashing-out-and-were-loving)
[JVL, Sarah Longwell, and Tim Miller relish Trumpâs losing streakâfrom +6 approval to â14âand why slipping GOP support could signal a Bush-styleâŚ](https://www.thebulwark.com/p/trump-is-crashing-out-and-were-loving)
Feb 10
⢠[Sarah Longwell](https://substack.com/@sarahlongwell), [Tim Miller](https://substack.com/@timmiller15), and [Jonathan V. Last](https://substack.com/@jvlast)
3,143
426
265
55:15
See all
### Ready for more?
Š 2026 Center Enterprises, Inc ¡ [Privacy](https://substack.com/privacy) â [Terms](https://substack.com/tos) â [Collection notice](https://substack.com/ccpa#personal-data-collected)
[Start your Substack](https://substack.com/signup?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=web&utm_content=footer)
[Get the app](https://substack.com/app/app-store-redirect?utm_campaign=app-marketing&utm_content=web-footer-button)
[Substack](https://substack.com/) is the home for great culture
 
This site requires JavaScript to run correctly. Please [turn on JavaScript](https://enable-javascript.com/) or unblock scripts |
| Readable Markdown | [](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!z6fC!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fccec6619-2672-40c9-8182-5d4dab958191_3000x1999.jpeg)
US President Donald Trump delivers remarks in front of the media in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington, DC on June 1, 2020. - US President Donald Trump was due to make a televised address to the nation on Monday after days of anti-racism protests against police brutality that have erupted into violence. The White House announced that the president would make remarks imminently after he has been criticized for not publicly addressing in the crisis in recent days. (Photo by Brendan Smialowski / AFP) (Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images)
It seems so clear now.
In June 2016âroughly seven weeks before Donald Trump formally received the Republican nomination for presidentâI wrote an extended essay in the *Huffington Post* assessing his behaviors. The title was self-explanatory: â[Too Sick to Lead: The Lethal Personality Disorder of Donald Trump](https://www.huffpost.com/entry/too-sick-to-lead-the-leth_b_10086768).â
By then, Trump had supplied us with overwhelming evidence of an ineradicable pathology which utterly disqualified him for the presidency. But few political observers wanted to touch such a volatile subject.
His party feared him. The media put him in their customary analytical boxes, parsing his every move as if he were something grander, yet more normal, than a mentally disordered demagogue bereft of principles and starved for adulation. And those mental health professionals who dared address the obvious were [chided by their peers](https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/16/health/analyzing-donald-trump-psychology.html) for psychoanalyzing a man they had never met.
But we *had* met himâceaselessly, for decades, and never more than in the year before June 2016, when cable news frequently broadcast his appearances in their entirety. His character disorder was klieg-lit; central to Trumpâs pathology was his uncontrollable need to flaunt it.
Most remarkable about his psychological illness is the utter consistency of his behaviors. My descriptions of his pathology, and how it would operate in office, are as applicable today as they were four years ago. Save for factual references specific to 2016, I need not change a word. This owes nothing to my special insight, and everything to Trumpâs inability to be anything other than what he was and always will be: a man far too disturbed to occupy the White House.
That he does underscores the core issue in 2020: Will a critical swath of voters, despite all weâve learned about his unfitness for the presidency, return this man to power?
No longer can we rationalize away his disabling instabilityânot for tax cuts, or judges, or ideology writ large. By deliberately averting their eyes from the incessant manifestations of his feral inner landscape, the GOP and much of the news media became complicit in his Electoral College victoryâand the damage he has inflicted on our democracy and society.
To capture Trumpâs singular abnormality, I opened my June 2016 article by describing a telling example from his past: his disturbingly bizarre and infantile practice of pretending to be someone else while calling a reporter to brag about his own romantic life. After describing an audiotape of Trumpâs pseudonymous 1991 phone call to *People* magazine boasting about his supposed romantic involvement with several ultra-famous womenâmade despite the fact that he was living with his future wife Marla MaplesâI pointed out that this behavior was not merely âself-aggrandizingâ but also âgratuitously cruel, heedless of all but self, reckless in his lust for attentionâ and, therefore, that it reflected on Trump's âpsychological fitness to be president.â
With this indubitably aberrant practice as preface, I argued that there is âonly one organizing principleâ that can make sense of Trumpâs âwildly oscillating utterances and behaviorâthe clinical definition of narcissistic personality disorder.â
> The Mayo Clinic [describes it](https://web.archive.org/web/20160523013955/http:/www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/narcissistic-personality-disorder/basics/definition/con-20025568) as âa mental disorder in which people have an inflated sense of their own importance, a deep need for admiration and a lack of empathy for others.â This is bad enough in selecting a spouse or a friend. But when applied to a prospective president, the symptoms are disqualifying.
With Trump ever in mind, try these. An exaggerated sense of self-importance. An unwarranted belief in your own superiority. A preoccupation with fantasies of your own success, power and brilliance. A craving for constant admiration. A consuming sense of entitlement. An expectation of special favors and unquestioning compliance.
A penchant for exploiting or disparaging others. A total inability to recognize the needs of anyone else. An incapacity to see those you meet as separate human beings. An unreasoning fury at people you perceive as thwarting your wishes or desires. A tendency to act on impulse. A superficial charm deployed to disguise a gift for manipulation.
A need to always be right. A refusal to acknowledge error. An inability to tolerate criticism or critics. A compulsion to conform your everâshifting sense of ârealityâ to satisfy your inner requirements. A tendency to lie so frequently and routinely that objective truth loses all meaning.
A belief that you are above the rules. An array of inconsistent statements and behaviors driven by your needs in the moment. An inability to assess the consequences of your actions in new or complex situations. In sum, a total incapacity to separate the world from your own psychodrama.
Recognize anyone? . . .
The annals of business are filled with such people, some of whom wind up in jail, others of whom die rich. But however puissant they become in their chosen realm, their sickness of mind and spirit cannot ruin a country. That power is reserved for presidents.
Indeed, Trumpâs rise simply swells his unwarranted belief that he can stride the world like a colossusânaked of judgment, knowledge, temperament or preparation. This reflects a fatal deficit in those who suffer this disorderâthey cannot see themselves as they are.
To the contrary, their grandiosity is a defense against feelings of inadequacy too deep and painful to acknowledge. By the consensus of mental health experts, this emotional impairment has a last fatal ingredientâthere is no cure. For a man like Donald Trump, life offers no lessons, no path forward save to continue as you have until, like Icarus, you fly too close to the sun.
This disability involves far more than a set of discrete character flaws, however grave, including those which suggest a lack of trustworthiness. We survived the dishonesty and paranoia of Richard Nixon, after all, albeit at considerable cost and only after forcing him from office.
But in many ways Nixon was well-equipped for the presidency, capable of navigating the larger world and understanding complex situations and peopleâas in China and its leaders. He did not reflexively substitute a grossly inflated sense of self for knowledge, strategy or preparation. His tragedy, and ours, was that his crippling inner wounds outstripped his proven strengths.
Donald Trump is altogether differentâand infinitely more dangerous. He is afflicted with a comprehensive and profound character disorder which leaves no corner of his psyche whole. And this dictatesâand explainsâevery aspect of his behavior.
Take his recourse to bullying and slander. âIâm a counterpuncher,â he rationalizes. â\[I\]âve been responding to what they did to me.â Now we understand, Donaldâyour enemies made you do it.
Really? So Heidi Cruz made him ridicule her looks on Twitter? That handicapped reporter made him imitate his disabilities at a rally? . . . And on and onâthe list of enemies he must demean is infinite.
A recent example typifies his psychological imbalance. Speaking at a rally in San Diego, he tried to shame an otherwise obscure federal judge in the city, who is presiding over a lawsuit against Trump University. Trump called the Indiana-born judge a âMexican,â a âhater of Donald Trumpâ and a âvery hostile personâ who had ârailroadedâ him. Heedless of his position or his audience, Trump wallowed in his personal grievances so long that his listeners grew restive. And so, yet again, the campaign for president descended into the poisonous murk of Trumpâs inner world.
This astoundingly graceless and unpresidential behavior is far too pointless and indiscriminate to qualify as strategy or tactics. The common thread in all this lashing outâoften at those who canât fight backâis that it has nothing to do with issues, or anything else one would expect from a normal candidate. It is another symptom of Trumpâs pathologyâthe visceral reflex to humiliate and degrade anyone who displeases him, no matter the context or situation.
Take the media. Where, one might ask, would Trump be without its constant and credulous attentions? But, like everyone else, the media can never do enough to feed his needs. He threatens the owners of newspapers with reprisals by the federal government, talks of changing libel laws to facilitate lawsuits for statements which affront him, proposes revoking FCC licenses for media which ruffle him. CNN is âvery unprofessionalâ; like so many others, Fox has treated him âvery unfairly.â
He refers to the media which cover him as âscum.â He singles out by name reporters who dare to challenge him. . . . After all, Trump says, heâs âfighting for survivalââever victimized by hostile forces who fail to recognize his innate superiority.
Opposition of any kind enrages him. He incites reprisals against protesters. He threatened violence in Cleveland as payback for the GOPâs âunfairness.â He fuels anger against Hispanics, Muslims, and other minorities whom he perceives as inimical. And neverânot onceâdoes he take any responsibility for stirring these toxic pots. For one of the symptoms of his disability is an absence of conscience or accountability.
So what did women do to him, one wonders? The offense was obviously grave, for his misogyny is endless and, it seems, uncontrollable. One can but identify the same symptoms which drive his comprehensive impulse to demeanâthe need to dominate, displeasure at feeling thwarted and, of course, a profound lack of empathy for anyone but himself.
But for âTrump,â ever beset, his empathy is boundless. His view of others vacillates wildly based solely on their deferenceâor lack of it. . . .
Which brings us to a central problem of Trumpâs warped psychologyâhe believes that filling the presidency requires nothing but the wonder of himself. This gives the lie to GOPâs most craven rationalization of its own capitulation: that a suddenly docile Trump will, as president, defer to a cadre of wise and experienced advisers drawn from the party establishment.
This is pernicious nonsense. Consistent with his character disorder, Trump proudly insists that his chief adviser is himself. Even were he so inclined, in order to learn from others he must know enough to discern good advice from bad. But such is his pathology that he feels no need to learn much of anything from anyone. And so, from the beginning, he has plunged us down the bottomless rabbit hole of his intellectual emptiness.
His ignorance and grandiosity form a lethal compound. He disowns NATO, unaware that he is playing into Putinâs hands . . . and imagines negotiating one-on-one with North Koreaâs psychotic leader. . . . Oblivious to the appalled reaction around the globe, he promises to compel the respect of world leaders through âthe aura of personality.â
His equally spurious domestic âproposals,â such as they may be, reflect nothing but the unreality of his own self-concept. . .
But to talk of Trump in terms of issues is to flatter him. Most of what he says is provisional, ever subject to change, and based on nothing but his needs at the moment. . . .
One can forecast the inevitable day-to-day damage to our countryâthe lashings out, the abuses of power, the mercurial and confidence-destroying lies and changes of mind, the havoc his distorted lens would wreak upon our institutions and our spirit. But most dangerous of all is the collision between a volatile world, a leader unable to perceive external reality, and the often-unbearable pressures of the presidency. That Trumpâs judgment would crack time and again is certainâthe only question is how dangerous the moment.
So how have we fallen prey to a man who, by the damning evidence of his own behavior, is psychologically unfit to be president? When did boasting top coherence; mindless posturing become strength; a talent for ridicule supplant experience or judgement; a gift for scapegoating surpass wisdom or generosity? Why must we even contemplate someone with this stunted inner landscape as the worldâs most powerful man? Why, indeed? But that was thenâ2016. In 2020 Americaâs electorate has experienced three and a half years of the most aberrant presidency in our history. We have no excuses left.
Our presidentâs sickness is ever on display. According to the *Washington Post*, as of May 29 Trump had made [more than 19,000 false or misleading claims](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/01/president-trump-made-19127-false-or-misleading-claims-1226-days/) in a little over 1,200 days in office. During this time, we have witnessed his manipulation of the Justice Department, attacks on the rule of law, refusal to honor congressional subpoenas, fascination with authoritarian leaders, assertions of unlimited power, and attempts to solicit or compel electoral assistance from foreign governments.
Hungry for attention, he subjects us to a constant stream of scurrilous tweets, false accusations, rank divisiveness, unhinged conspiracy theories, blatant racial innuendos, shameless denials of reality, reflexive self-pity, unbounded grandiosity, puerile insults to real or imagined enemies, and claims of superior expertise in a multitude of areas where his abysmal ignorance is manifest. His sole concern is for himself.
This confluence of anti-social behaviors would be shocking in a relative or coworker; in a president, they are frightening and disorienting. Since his inauguration, Trump has debased the coinage of the presidency, eroded the boundaries on presidential misconduct, and poisoned the well of civic decency. His crippling dysfunction is now ours.
These behaviors have caused an increasing number of mental health professional to issue warnings about Trumpâs psychological condition. In 2017, forensic psychiatrist Bandy X. Lee edited a book, *[The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump](https://www.amazon.com/gp/B07NL1NHCR/)*, that included essays from dozens of psychiatrists, psychologists, and mental health professionals. And last December, two weeks before Trumpâs impeachment, Dr. Lee [submitted to Congress a petition](https://web.archive.org/web/20191209193923/https:/dangerouscase.org/petition-to-the-judiciary-committee/), with 650 other psychiatrists, psychologists, and mental health professionals as co-signatories, which included this disturbing admonition:
> What makes Donald Trump so dangerous is the brittleness of his sense of worth. Any slight or criticism is experienced as a humiliation and degradation. To cope with the resultant hollow and empty feeling, he reacts with what is referred to as narcissistic rage. He is unable to take responsibility for any error, mistake, or failing. His default in that situation is to blame others and to attack the perceived source of his humiliation. These attacks of narcissistic rage can be brutal and destructive.â
Further, [Lee explained to the London Independent](https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/trump-mental-state-impeachment-psychiatrist-petition-congress-a9232386.html), Trump was âdoubling and . . . tripling down on his delusionsâ; âramping up his conspiracy theoriesâ; and âshowing a great deal of cruelty and vindictivenessâ in his âaccelerated, repetitive tweets.â
Recent examples include [his vicious allegations](https://www.politico.com/news/2020/05/12/trump-conspiracy-theory-msnbc-251108) that, twenty years ago, Joe Scarborough murdered a woman who worked in his Florida congressional office. In reality, she died of a heart attack when Scarborough was 500 miles away. But Trumpâs cruelty caused her anguished widower to implore Twitter to delete his sadistic tweets.
A related sign of emotional instability is Trumpâs obsession with projecting dominance and strengthâthe underside of which is a debilitating admixture of neediness and insecurity.
Recent examples abound. Some would be seriocomic were he not Americaâs president:
- As reported by Ashley Parker and Josh Dawsey [in the](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-increasingly-preoccupied-with-defending-his-physical-and-mental-health/2020/06/22/c7e0a95c-b3ed-11ea-9b0f-c797548c1154_story.html) *[Washington Post](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-increasingly-preoccupied-with-defending-his-physical-and-mental-health/2020/06/22/c7e0a95c-b3ed-11ea-9b0f-c797548c1154_story.html)*, Trump sidetracked a cabinet meeting with a lengthy re-enactment of his supposedly stellar performanceâthree years priorâon a cognitive screening test.
- After taking refuge in an underground bunker when protesters ringed the White House, he furiously denied itâclaiming to have been conducting [a snap inspection tour](https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/06/donald-trump-denies-hiding-bunker-during-protests).
- When a videotape captured his halting descent down a ramp after speaking at West Point, Trump delivered a rambling fifteen-minute revisionist history at his rally in Tulsaâblaming, among other things, [slippery shoes](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-increasingly-preoccupied-with-defending-his-physical-and-mental-health/2020/06/22/c7e0a95c-b3ed-11ea-9b0f-c797548c1154_story.html).
Other examples are alarming, indeed ominous. His constant calls to âdominateâ the streets during protests following the death of George Floyd. His threats to deploy active duty troops on American soil. His misuse of military personnel to clear peaceful protesters near Lafayette Squareâall so that he could hold a borrowed Bible aloft in front of a damaged church, a videotaped piece of authoritarian theater.
The gnawing hunger of Trumpâs misshapen psyche dominates Carl Bernsteinâs appalling new account for CNN of the presidentâs conversations with foreign leaders, detailing in the starkest terms the consequences of investing someone of his pathology with the power of the American presidency.
[Writes Bernstein](https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/29/politics/trump-phone-calls-national-security-concerns/index.html):
> Trump was so consistently unprepared for discussion of serious issues, so often outplayed in his conversations with powerful leaders like . . . Vladimir Putin and Turkish president Recep ErdoÄan, and so abusive to leaders of Americaâs principal allies, that the calls helped convince some senior U.S. officialsâincluding his former secretaries of state and defense, two national security advisers and his longest-serving chief of staffâthat the president himself posed a danger to the national security of the United States . . . \[and\] to conclude that the president was often âdelusional,â as two sources put it, in his dealings with foreign leaders.
Central to these conversations was Trumpâs disabling absorption with himself: âTrump incessantly boasted to his fellow heads of state, including . . . North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un, about his own wealth, genius, âgreatâ accomplishments as president, and the âidiocyâ of his Oval Office predecessors. . . . In his phone exchanges with Putin . . . the president talked mostly about himself . . . \[while\] obsequiously courting Putinâs admiration and approval.â Adds Bernstein: âThe common, overwhelming dynamic that characterizes Trumpâs conversations with both authoritarian dictators and leaders of the worldâs greatest democracies is his consistent assertion of himself as the defining subject and subtext of the calls.â
But for allies, Trumpâs manner was the opposite of his pandering to the authoritarians: bullying, abusive, and riven with grievances. âEverything was always personalized,â a source told Bernstein, âwith everybody doing terrible things to rip us offâwhich meant ripping âmeââTrumpâoff.â With females, Trump added a withering misogyny. âHis most vicious attacks,â Bernstein relates, âwere aimed at women heads of state. In conversations with both \[Theresa\] May and \[Angela\] Merkel, the president demeaned and denigrated them in diatribes described as ânear-sadistic.ââ
Other consistent features of these phone calls were Trumpâs ignorance and dissociation from reality. âTwo sources,â Bernstein reports, âcompared many of the presidentâs conversations with foreign leaders to Trumpâs recent press âbriefingsâ on the coronavirus pandemic: free form, fact-deficient stream-of-consciousness ramblings, full of fantasy and off-the-wall pronouncements based on his intuitions, guesswork, the opinions of Fox News TV hosts and social media misinformation.â
Bernstein concludes by quoting a senior official who summarizes the grip of Trumpâs personality disorder on his conduct of foreign affairs: âThere was no sense of âTeam Americaâ or of . . . certain democratic principles and leadership of the free world. . . . The opposite. It was like the United States had disappeared. It was always âJust me.ââ
But, for now, all else is overshadowed by Trumpâs catastrophic mishandling of COVID-19âa case study in the literally lethal consequences of his hydra-headed disorder. This is precisely what I meant when, in 2016, I wrote about the dangerous collision between âvolatile world, a leader unable to perceive external reality, and the often**\-**unbearable pressures of the presidency.â Trump need not precipitate a nuclear exchange for his warped psychology to cause tens of thousands of needless American deaths.
It has. Last month disease modelers at Columbia [estimated](https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/20/us/coronavirus-distancing-deaths.html) that we would have incurred roughly 36,000 fewer fatalities had Trump initiated social distancing one week earlier, and 54,000 deaths had it started two weeks earlier. Instead, fearful that acknowledging the seriousness of the coronavirus would have adverse political consequences, Trump chose misleading the public over protecting lives.
Inexorably, the deadly pandemic overwhelmed Trumpâs self-created alternate realityâin which denying its lethality substituted for action. So he substituted yet another fantasy: that his proactive leadership in fighting the virus had saved countless lives and defeated the pandemic.
Even as the death toll mounted, he urged state governments to reopen the economyâdismissing life-saving public health measures recommended by his own government. COVID-19, [he told Sean Hannity](https://www.foxnews.com/media/trump-hannity-coronavirus-fading-away-tulsa-rally), is âfading away.â A week later, we suffered the [greatest number of new cases since the pandemic began](https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/us/coronavirus-us-cases.html).
Events in the real world provide a roadmap of Trumpâs delusions. The coronavirus spiked in the states that were the swiftest to reopen. The European Union has [banned Americans](https://www.nytimes.com/article/eu-travel-ban-explained-usa.html) as threats to public health. Contradicting Trump, [Anthony Fauci warned Congress](https://www.c-span.org/video/?473229-1/white-house-coronavirus-task-force-members-testify-federal-response-pandemic) that âthe virus is not going to disappear,â adding that âwe are still in the middle of a serious outbreak.â
No matter to Trump. In his imaginary America, the real problem became that we were testing too much, thereby increasing the count of new cases.
By then, as his pathology dictates, Trump had put blame for the pandemic on China, the World Health Organization, the media, Barack Obama, the intelligence community, and the CDC. And he had discovered the real victim of COVID-19: himself. In *Vanity Fair*, Gabriel Sherman [reported Trump telling a confidant](https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/05/trump-whines-about-his-covid-19-victimhood-as-campaign-flails): âThis is so unfair to me! Everything was going great. We were cruising to reelection!â
Instead, the pandemic has underscored Trumpâs complete indifference to other human beings. And not just the vulnerable, the sick, and the dead. He insisted that West Point graduates return to hear his commencement speech in the middle of a pandemic. He scheduled large indoor rallies in Tulsa and Phoenix, surefire super-spreaders, so that he could bask in adoring crowds.
When public health officials in Charlotte inquired about health measures for the GOP convention, Trump moved it to Jacksonvilleâsimply to ensure himself a jam-packed arena filled with unmasked faces, risk be damned. Over a three-week period of public statements amid the pandemic back in April, [the](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/13-hours-of-trump-the-president-fills-briefings-with-attacks-and-boasts-but-little-empathy/2020/04/25/7eec5ab0-8590-11ea-a3eb-e9fc93160703_story.html) *[Washington Post](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/13-hours-of-trump-the-president-fills-briefings-with-attacks-and-boasts-but-little-empathy/2020/04/25/7eec5ab0-8590-11ea-a3eb-e9fc93160703_story.html)* [reported](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/13-hours-of-trump-the-president-fills-briefings-with-attacks-and-boasts-but-little-empathy/2020/04/25/7eec5ab0-8590-11ea-a3eb-e9fc93160703_story.html), Trump spoke for some thirteen hoursâof which he spent two hours attacking others, forty-five minutes praising himself and his administration, but just four-and-a-half minutes expressing rote sympathy for coronavirus victims and front-line workers.
Further, the *[Post](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/01/president-trump-made-19127-false-or-misleading-claims-1226-days/)* [related in late May](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/01/president-trump-made-19127-false-or-misleading-claims-1226-days/), âThe coronavirus pandemic has spawned a whole new genre of Trumpâs falsehoods. The category in just a few months has reached 800 claims, with his advocacy for hydroxychloroquine as a possible cure, based on minimal and flimsy evidence, already reaching Bottomless Pinocchio status.â As Trumpâs confidant told Sherman: âHe lives in his own fucking world.â
In that world, Trump is free from the constraints of constitutional democracy.
To stave off defeat, he and his party are striving to prevent the universal voting by mail necessitated by the pandemic, while groundlessly asserting that the mail-in balloting currently available guarantees massive voter fraud by the Democratic Party. Already, [Trump is claiming](https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2020/06/24/trump_this_will_be_most_corrupt_election_in_the_history_of_our_country.html) that the 2020 election âwill be, in my opinion, the most corrupt election in the history of our country, and we cannot let this happen.â
This is insane. But an increasingly serious body of opinion anticipates that Trump will try to maintain power by denying the legitimacy of the November election. This captures how completely Trumpâs sickness has consumed usâexpecting our president to subvert American democracy is becoming our new normal.
The problem of Trump transcends party or ideology, and so does our need to be rid of him. For there is no constitutional guarantee against a president too mentally ill to respect its termsâand a party too craven to stop him.
Until further notice, we have both. |
| Shard | 173 (laksa) |
| Root Hash | 3547606719086444173 |
| Unparsed URL | com,thebulwark!www,/p/how-has-donald-trumps-mental-state-affected-his-presidency s443 |