ā¹ļø Skipped - page is already crawled
| Filter | Status | Condition | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| HTTP status | PASS | download_http_code = 200 | HTTP 200 |
| Age cutoff | PASS | download_stamp > now() - 6 MONTH | 0 months ago |
| History drop | PASS | isNull(history_drop_reason) | No drop reason |
| Spam/ban | PASS | fh_dont_index != 1 AND ml_spam_score = 0 | ml_spam_score=0 |
| Canonical | PASS | meta_canonical IS NULL OR = '' OR = src_unparsed | Not set |
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| URL | https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle/bike-test-compact-folding-bikes |
| Last Crawled | 2026-04-07 14:22:42 (1 day ago) |
| First Indexed | 2017-10-08 16:09:36 (8 years ago) |
| HTTP Status Code | 200 |
| Meta Title | Bike test: Compact folding bikes Birdy vs Brompton | Cycling UK |
| Meta Description | When it collapses to the size of a suitcase, you need never be without your bike. Dan Joyce test rides the budget Birdy World Sport and the 2-speed Brompton S2L |
| Meta Canonical | null |
| Boilerpipe Text | Trains, buses, car boots, boats, aeroplanes, offices, cloakrooms, hallways, studio flats ā folding bikes go where others wonāt fit or arenāt freely allowed. The smaller they pack down, the more loopholes theyāll slip through. For example, trains in the UK carry ācompact, fully folding cycles with wheels up to 20" in diameterā¦ without restrictionā.
Two of the best compacts are the Brompton and the Birdy. Both cost from around Ā£1,000, which is a lot more than an entry-level Dahon (rebadged or otherwise). Yet for long-term usage, itās money well spent.
A compact folder enables you to integrate cycling into your everyday life so deeply that it may transform the way you think about transport. Moreover, the initial cost will be recouped in saved bus or taxi fares or petrol.
In its 40-year history, the Brompton has evolved from a bike-rail solution for the cognoscenti into a marketing-friendly, middle-class icon. It now exists in a variety of Ć la carte formats.
I picked a 2-speed partly because Iāve not used the Brompton derailleur before, but also because it saves about 600g over the 3-speed, and low weight is a big deal for a bike youāll often hold in one hand. With mudguards, flat S-type handlebar, Schwalbe Kojak tyres, and the all-important front luggage block, it costs Ā£970.
The German Birdy is even more premium priced than the Brompton; standard models start at Ā£2,069. However, manufacturer Riese und MĆ¼ller also offers a couple of āmodel-T Fordā versions: the World Birdy Comfort (Ā£1,439 with Nexus 8-speed hub, dynamo lights, and rear rack); and the Ā£1,169 World Birdy Sport, which comes with 8-speed derailleur gearing and in any colour you like as long as itās black.
(Note that in common with UK retailers, Iām transposing the name and calling this bike the Birdy World Sport.)
Frame and folding: Brompton
One of the reasons that the Brompton is so compact is that it doesnāt simply fold in half. The rear triangle pivots behind the bottom bracket, enabling the rear wheel to tuck underneath the main frame tube. The bike stays upright sitting on its haunches, so it can be parked like this.
In earlier models, there was nothing but your weight on the saddle stopping the rear end tucking under, which was an issue if you picked up the unfolded bike (or bunny hopped itā¦). Now thereās a catch to hold the rear triangle in place.
The top of the rear triangle has a rubber suspension bumper where it butts against the seat tube. There are two grades of suspension available: standard or firm. Unless youāre very light, pick firm. If itās too soft, the suspension bobs through each crank revolution, robbing a little energy and making the bike wallow.
Tucking the rear wheel under is step one of the folding procedure. Step two, once youāve ensured the left-hand crank points forward, is to undo the frame hinge and, holding the stem, lift the front end of the bike up and back; a catch on the left-hand fork blade hooks over the drive-side chain stay.
Step three is to undo the seatpost quick release, lower the seatpost, then refasten the quick release; the dropped seatpost locks the rear triangle into its folded position. Step four is to undo the stem hinge and let the stem and handlebar drop down; a nodule on the stem fits into a bracket on the fork crown, holding the stem and bar in place.
Finally, rotate the cranks backwards so that the right-hand pedal is next to the tyre, and then fold the left-hand pedal. You can now pick up the bike by the saddle nose or main frame tube, or on smooth surfaces roll it on its castors ā something thatās easier with the handlebar left unfolded.
Written down, this sounds fairly involved. In practice, it becomes second nature and youāll do it comfortably in 10-15 seconds. It takes about the same amount of time to unfold, despite the fact that the hinges arenāt self-locking.
With a standard seatpost, Iām fortuitously the ideal height (1.77m) and can just raise it to its maximum extension. As the test bike had the longer āextendedā seatpost, I had to faff with saddle height like everyone else, and I sorely missed the height markers of the Birdyās seatpost.
The speed of folding/unfolding is useful for commuting, where youāll be doing it multiple times on any mixed-mode journey. It also means you can avoid carrying the bike more than you absolutely have to. Better to push it along the platform, or drag it on its castors, than heft it.
At 11kg, the S2L is no heavyweight (in fact, itās 1.4kg lighter than my old 3-speed Brompton), but itās difficult to walk any distance with ā and I say that as a fit and healthy, average-sized bloke. Slightly built owners will struggle. A shoulder strap would be a useful accessory.
The frame has fittings for mudguards, which donāt affect the fold, and dedicated racks front and rear. The front luggage system is excellent, with a choice of bags to fit the optional mount on the head tube. The Brompton rear rack is largely superfluous, mostly adding weight plus some stability to the folded bike. There arenāt any bottle mounts.
While the frame is a marvel of metallurgical origami, there are a couple of things Iād change. One is the fact that the rear mudguard sits on top the chain stay brace. Since this gets hosed with water, it eventually rusts away ā unless you choose the āSuperlightā titanium option. The second thing is the fork offset: thereās too much. More on that later.
Frame and folding: Birdy
Unlike the Brompton, the Birdy is aluminium rather than steel and thereās no hinge in the main frame, so it canāt flex there. Stronger and heavier riders will appreciate this. Without a frame hinge, it canāt fold as compactly either, but the folding process is still ingenious.
First, you need to put it into top gear (otherwise the chain will fall off when you fold the bike). Second, level the cranks with the left one forward. Third, lift the front end off the ground, unclip the front wheel at its suspension elastomer, and then fold the wheel back on itself, rotating it around its own suspension pivots.
Fourth, unclip the rear wheel and tuck it under, similar to the Brompton. Fifth, lower the seatpost to lock the rear swing-arm in position. Finally, undo and fold down the handlebar.
The Birdy evidently holds the record for the fastest fold, at 4.9 seconds, but Iāve never got anywhere near this and it always took me longer to fold than the Brompton. It felt like more hassle too, perhaps due to a lack of familiarity. So I didnāt fold the Birdy when I didnāt have to. With the Brompton, it is no bother: you fold it without thinking.
I encountered a couple of snags folding the Birdy. The handlebar wouldnāt fold flush, as the grip overlapped the quick release lever. This might be solved by: narrower rear dropouts; removing the kickstand (youāll need a spacer instead); and/or having Allen-headed wheel bolts instead of a quick release with a cam lever.
You also need to take care to keep the rear derailleur out of the front wheel when folding. Thereās little space between them.
When itās folded, the Birdy isnāt any harder to carry than the Brompton. Itās just bulkier. It will easily fit an end-of-carriage luggage rack, but getting it from one end of a busy train carriage to the other is awkward. I collided with knees, elbows, newspapers and tempers.
Unfolded, the Birdy benefits from elastomer suspension front and rear ā 30mm and 40mm respectively. The rear is a bumper for the swing-arm, like the Bromptonās. The front is part of an unusual-looking leading link fork. This tracks well and doesnāt dive during braking. For my weight (65kg), the standard elastomers were fine. If I were to change them, Iād fit the firm ones but soft is also an option.
The World Sport comes with a kickstand (whose rubber foot fell off) and mudguards with sturdy stays. They need to be strong as the folded bike rests on these mudguards. A low-rider front rack and a cantilevered rear rack are available as extras, although Iād fit a large Carradice SQR block and a Super C Saddlebag instead. As with the Brompton, there are no bottle mounts.
Ride
The Brompton has very quick steering due to its tiny amount of trail. Some will characterise this as ānippyā, others ānervousā. With both hands on the handlebar, the handling is OK. Signalling requires concentration, especially when youāre descending or the road surface is rough.
If you use one of Bromptonās excellent front bags, the extra weight over the front wheel makes the steering less skittish, although even without a front bag itās not so unusual that you canāt get used it. Yet Iām sure the handling could be much improved by reducing the forkās offset to zero. This might necessitate other design tweaks to prevent compromising the fold.
The S-bar provides a sportier riding position than the M-bar Iām used to. I liked it. You end up with more weight on your hands, so for comfort Iād recommend bar ends (up to about 80-90mm wonāt interfere with the fold) or flared, ergonomic grips; Ergon GP3 grips would address both issues. Schwalbeās Kojak tyres are a good match for the S-bar, helping these small wheels hold their speed better.
Nippy around town is one thing; if youāre going further, the Brompton is seldom the best choice. While some owners tour on Bromptons, and Iāve done 50-mile rides on mine, single-digit mileages are what this bike does best. Consequently, I think fewer gears (and less weight to carry) is the better choice.
The Birdy rides less like a folder and more like a conventional bike. The handling is stable because itās got more trail, so you can tackle descents and everyday manoeuvres with greater confidence. As the reach is roomier, youāll feel less perched on it if youāre taller than average. The unusually high bottom bracket suits longer-legged riders too.
The simple elastomer suspension front and rear goes a long way to offsetting the issues that small wheels have compared to large ones. It removes the āchatterā you get from anything other than a billiard table smooth road.
Itās more comfortable, since the bike absorbs small bumps before you do. It also improves the rolling performance, because the wheels flow over bumps rather than being buffeted or baulked by them.
Iād have no hesitation in doing all-day rides on a Birdy, with or without luggage. Like any bike with suspension you canāt lock out, it rides best if you sit and spin; riding it out of the saddle is like running on a trampoline.
Components
Convoluted cable runs can affect the braking performance of any folder that uses mechanical callipers. Happily, the Bromptonās long-reach sidepulls are better than they were in the past. Theyāre now dual pivots, fitted with decent Fibrax blocks, and the all-metal levers are less spongy. I had no problems scrubbing off speed.
The callipers lack quick releases, so you need to deflate the tyre to get the wheel out or in, which is odd.
The Birdy uses V-brakes, which are more powerful ā just as well given the higher speeds you can comfortably reach on this bike. The pads arenāt perpendicular to the brake arms, particularly at the rear, so watch for uneven pad wear. Parallel-push V-brakes would be a solution but Iām not aware of anywhere you can get them, other than eBay.
The Bromptonās two-speed gearing is fine around town: you get one gear for starting off or climbing modest hills and another for cruising along. Both are a little high, so consider one of the gear reduction options (7% or 18%) at point of purchase.
The shifter, which indicates the gear with a + or a ā, turns the Brompton chain tensioner into a derailleur by moving the top jockey wheel. Itās not as slick as Shimano, especially shifting against the spring (down), but it works OK.
The Birdy uses an 8-speed twistgrip and a Shimano Claris derailleur thatās unremarkable except for the long chain guide projecting from the bottom. This is for the loose chain to hang on when the rear wheel tucks under. Claris will cope with a 32 sprocket, so itās a shame an 11-30 cassette is fitted.
Bottom gear is a bit high for the day rides or tours this bike is capable of. Iād be tempted to try an 11-34 cassette, using a longer B-screw to nudge the derailleur away from this bigger cassette.
Small wheels need efficient tyres to roll as well as big ones, and both these bikes have them. The Birdy has Schwalbe Marathon Racer tyres, which are a big improvement from the stodgy Impac Streetpacs that I criticised the World Sport for last time I tested one.
The Brompton, meanwhile, has Schwalbe Kojak tyres because I asked for them. You can choose between Kojaks, Schwalbe Marathons and Brompton Kevlar tyres when you use Bromptonās online ābike builderā.
The Birdy rides less like a folder and more like a conventional bikeā¦ Iād not hesitate to do all-day rides on it. I didnāt fold the Birdy when I didnāt have to. With the Brompton, it is no bother: you fold it without thinking
Dan Joyce, Cycle magazine editor
Verdict
It boils down to what you want most: a fantastic folder that rides OK, or a small-wheeler that rides really well and folds OK. The Brompton is the better mixed-mode commuter because of its more compact fold, whereas the Birdyās superior ride makes it the better choice for mixed-mode journeys you want to enjoy, such as touring and leisure riding.
The Birdy is arguably more versatile too, being a more capable commuter than the Brompton is a tourer. But versatility isnāt everything.
The Brompton fills one role exceptionally well: short-distance utility transport that blends into the background when you donāt need it as a bike. Thatās all I really need a folder for, so Iāll probably replace my 16-year-old Brompton with a newer version when the time comes.
Your mileage, as ever, may vary. If you have the chance to test ride and test fold both bikes, take it.
First published in Cycle magazine, August/September 2017 issue. All information correct at time of publishing. |
| Markdown | [Skip to main content](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle/bike-test-compact-folding-bikes#main-content)
- [Donate](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle/bike-test-compact-folding-bikes?form=general-donation "Donate")
- [Membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/join-cycling-uk-today "Membership")
- [Log in](https://www.cyclinguk.org/user/login "Log in")
- [Logout](https://www.cyclinguk.org/user/logout "Logout")
- [Search](https://www.cyclinguk.org/site-search "Search")
- Accessibility
Toggle submenu
## Accessibility tools
Colour
 Switch to color theme
 Switch to blue theme
 Switch to high visibility theme
 Switch to soft theme
Text
A Set font size to 100%
A Set font size to 125%
A Set font size to 150%
## Accessibility tools
Colour
 Switch to color theme
 Switch to blue theme
 Switch to high visibility theme
 Switch to soft theme
Text
A Set font size to 100%
A Set font size to 125%
A Set font size to 150%
[Menu](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle/bike-test-compact-folding-bikes#off-canvas "Menu")
- Routes
Toggle submenu
Routes
Cycling is a beautiful thing. From touring the countryside to descending a mountainside, whatever type of cyclist you are, we have a whole host of inspirational cycling routes for you
[Our routes](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes)
- [Routes](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes "Routes")
- [Planning your route](https://www.cyclinguk.org/journey-planner "Planning your route")
- [All GPX routes](https://www.cyclinguk.org/all-our-cycling-routes)
- [Our Adventure Series](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/adventure-series "Adventure Series")
- [Royal Chilterns Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/royal-chilterns-way "Royal Chilterns Way")
- [Marcher Castles Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/marcher-castles-way "Marcher Castles Way")
- [Traws Eryri](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/traws-eryri "Traws Eryri")
- [Rebellion Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/rebellion-way "Rebellion Way")
- [Cantii Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/cantii-way "Cantii Way")
- [West Kernow Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/west-kernow-way "West Kernow Way")
- [King Alfredās Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/king-alfreds-way "King Alfredās Way")
- [Help fund our next cycle route](https://www.cyclinguk.org/long-distance-routes-appeal)
Donate to our new long-distance cycle route
Donate to help make the next inspiring and breath-taking cycling route in our Adventure Series a reality. Any amount you can donate helps, and all donors will receive perks based on their donation amount.
[Donate today](https://www.cyclinguk.org/long-distance-routes-appeal)
- Go cycling
Toggle submenu
Go cycling
Our mission is to enable millions more to cycle. As independent experts we are able to offer a range of impartial advice, guides, reviews, inspiration and routes to help you experience the joy of cycling. We also have community projects and a network of thousands of clubs, groups and events
[Join today](https://www.cyclinguk.org/join)
- [All advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/advice "All advice")
- [Beginner advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/advice/beginner-cycling "Beginner advice")
- [Cycling as a family](https://www.cyclinguk.org/advice/cycling-family "Cycling as a family")
- [Different types of cycling](https://www.cyclinguk.org/advice/type-cycling "Different types of cycling ")
- [Bikes, cycles and kit](https://www.cyclinguk.org/bikes-cycles-and-kit "Bikes, cycles and kit")
- [Seasonal advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/seasonal-advice "Seasonal advice")
- [Safety advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-safety-advice "Safety advice ")
- [Maintenance advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/essential-cycle-maintenance-advice "Maintenance advice")
- [Clubs and groups](https://www.cyclinguk.org/local-groups "Ride together (clubs and groups)")
- [Events](https://www.cyclinguk.org/special-events "Events")
Seasonal cycling advice
As we head into spring, explore our seasonal cycling advice to keep you riding through winter and get you and your bike ready for the warmer months
[Cycle in all weather](https://www.cyclinguk.org/seasonal-advice)
- Campaigning
Toggle submenu
Campaigning
For more than 140 years, Cycling UK has campaigned to make cycling safe and accessible for everyone. Every year, thousands of people support our campaigns and together we achieve real change for cyclists. We help make our roads safer for all and improve access to the outdoors
[Take action for cycling](https://action.cyclinguk.org/page/169747/action/1?ea.tracking.id=TA)
- [Our campaigns](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns "Our campaigns")
- [Local cycle campaigning](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/cycle-advocacy-network "Cycle Advocacy Network")
- [Cyclists' Defence Fund](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/cyclists-defence-fund "Cyclists' Defence Fund")
- [Sign up for updates](https://www.cyclinguk.org/subscribe-cycling-uk "Sign up for updates")
- [Cycling UK statistics](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/statistics "Cycling UK statistics")
- [Cycling UK views and briefings](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-campaigning/briefings "Cycling UK views and briefings ")
- [My ride. Our right](https://www.cyclinguk.org/my-ride-our-right)
- [Scotland election 2026](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/elections-2026/scotland)
- [Wales Senedd election 2026](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/elections-2026/wales)
Elections 2026
Our manifestos for Scotland and Wales call on future governments to make it safe to walk, wheel or cycle every day. Email your candidates today and ask them to support this vision.
[Contact your candidates](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/elections-2026)
- Make a difference
Toggle submenu
Make a difference
There are many different ways you can get involved with Cycling UK and help us support many more people to cycle. Join, donate, volunteer or be involved in our inspiring campaigns and projects
[Make a difference](https://www.cyclinguk.org/make-a-difference)
- [Become a member](https://www.cyclinguk.org/join-cycling-uk-today "Become a member")
- [Give a gift membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/gift-membership "Give a gift membership")
- [Group membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/join-group "Group membership")
- [Cycle Activity Provider membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-activity-provider-membership "Cycle Activity Provider membership")
- [Ways of giving](https://www.cyclinguk.org/make-a-difference/giving "Ways of giving")
- [Fundraising](https://www.cyclinguk.org/make-a-difference/fundraising)
- [Lottery and raffle](https://www.cyclinguk.org/make-a-difference/win)
- [Corporate partnerships](https://www.cyclinguk.org/corporate-partners "Corporate partnerships")
- [Join the conversation](https://www.cyclinguk.org/join-conversation "Join the conversation")
- [Volunteer](https://www.cyclinguk.org/volunteer "Volunteer")
Itās free wills month
Your legacy can help create a happier, healthier and greener world through cycling. Write or update your will for free this March with Octopus Legacy, and ensure we can stand up for cyclists for generations to come
[Get your free will](https://www.cyclinguk.org/member-benefits/free-will-writing-service-octopus-legacy)
- Services
Toggle submenu
Services
Cycling UK offers a range of cycling-related services to support and advise our members, the wider cycling community and employers. If you are looking for cycling insurance, training courses, help to run an event or if youād like to be a Cycle Friendly Employer we can help.
[Our services](https://www.cyclinguk.org/services)
- [Insurance](https://www.cyclinguk.org/insurance "Insurance")
- [Incident Line](https://www.cyclinguk.org/member-benefits/cycling-uk-incident-line "Incident Line")
- [Workplaces](https://www.cyclinguk.org/workplaces "Support for workplaces")
- [Cycle Friendly Employer](https://www.cyclinguk.org/workplaces/cycle-friendly-employer "Cycle Friendly Employer")
- [Cycle Friendly Building](https://www.cyclinguk.org/workplaces/cycle-friendly-building)
- [Employee membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/workplaces/employee-membership "Employer membership")
- [Courses](https://www.cyclinguk.org/courses-and-training/courses-available "Courses")
- [Organising events](https://www.cyclinguk.org/ride-and-event-organiser-insurance "Organising events")
- [Cycle magazine](https://www.cyclinguk.org/publications/cycle "Cycle magazine")
- [Support for clubs and groups](https://www.cyclinguk.org/local-groups "Support for clubs and groups")
- [Consultancy and advisory services](https://www.cyclinguk.org/consultancy-and-advisory-services)
Cycling groups and clubs
Being a member of a cycling club allows you to meet like-minded people who provide motivation, mutual support and companionship through a shared love of cycling.
[Find a cycle group](https://www.cyclinguk.org/local-groups)
- Our charity
Toggle submenu
Our charity
Cycling UK is more than just a membership charity, which provides you with excellent insurance, information and a magazine. We also run a range of projects, groups and programmes across all nations of the UK to encourage people to cycle
[Contact us](https://www.cyclinguk.org/contact)
- [Who we are](https://www.cyclinguk.org/about "Who we are")
- [Our projects](https://www.cyclinguk.org/community-cycling-projects "Our projects")
- [Contact us](https://www.cyclinguk.org/contact "Contact us")
- [Jobs](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycling-uk-jobs "Jobs")
- [Publications](https://www.cyclinguk.org/publications)
- [News, blogs and features](https://www.cyclinguk.org/news-blogs-features-and-articles "News, blogs and features")
- [Cycling UK in England](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycling-uk-england "Cycling UK in England")
- [Cycling UK in Scotland](https://www.cyclinguk.org/scotland "Cycling UK in Scotland")
- [Cycling UK in Northern Ireland](https://www.cyclinguk.org/northern-ireland "Cycling UK in Northern Ireland")
- [Cycling UK in Wales](https://www.cyclinguk.org/wales "Cycling UK in Wales")
- [Our strategy to 2029](https://www.cyclinguk.org/strategy "Our strategy to 2029")
- [Cycling UK shop](https://www.cyclinguk.org/shop "Cycling UK shop")
Community Cycle Clubs
Community Cycle Clubs are inclusive local groups across England that help people of all backgrounds enjoy healthier, happier and more connected lives through accessible cycling, which we support with training, equipment and ongoing guidance so clubs can grow and thrive
[Ready to ride](https://www.cyclinguk.org/community-cycle-clubs)
- Search
Toggle submenu
## Search the website
# Bike test: Compact folding bikes Birdy vs Brompton
**By Dan**
Bromptonās S2L (left) folds smaller than the Birdy World Sport (right), but the latter is a more versatile ride
When it collapses to the size of a suitcase, you need never be without your bike. Dan Joyce test rides the budget Birdy World Sport and the 2-speed Brompton S2L
Trains, buses, car boots, boats, aeroplanes, offices, cloakrooms, hallways, studio flats ā folding bikes go where others wonāt fit or arenāt freely allowed. The smaller they pack down, the more loopholes theyāll slip through. For example, trains in the UK carry ācompact, fully folding cycles with wheels up to 20" in diameterā¦ without restrictionā.
Two of the best compacts are the Brompton and the Birdy. Both cost from around Ā£1,000, which is a lot more than an entry-level Dahon (rebadged or otherwise). Yet for long-term usage, itās money well spent.
A compact folder enables you to integrate cycling into your everyday life so deeply that it may transform the way you think about transport. Moreover, the initial cost will be recouped in saved bus or taxi fares or petrol.
In its 40-year history, the Brompton has evolved from a bike-rail solution for the cognoscenti into a marketing-friendly, middle-class icon. It now exists in a variety of Ć la carte formats.
I picked a 2-speed partly because Iāve not used the Brompton derailleur before, but also because it saves about 600g over the 3-speed, and low weight is a big deal for a bike youāll often hold in one hand. With mudguards, flat S-type handlebar, Schwalbe Kojak tyres, and the all-important front luggage block, it costs Ā£970.
The German Birdy is even more premium priced than the Brompton; standard models start at Ā£2,069. However, manufacturer Riese und MĆ¼ller also offers a couple of āmodel-T Fordā versions: the World Birdy Comfort (Ā£1,439 with Nexus 8-speed hub, dynamo lights, and rear rack); and the Ā£1,169 World Birdy Sport, which comes with 8-speed derailleur gearing and in any colour you like as long as itās black.
(Note that in common with UK retailers, Iām transposing the name and calling this bike the Birdy World Sport.)
## Frame and folding: Brompton
One of the reasons that the Brompton is so compact is that it doesnāt simply fold in half. The rear triangle pivots behind the bottom bracket, enabling the rear wheel to tuck underneath the main frame tube. The bike stays upright sitting on its haunches, so it can be parked like this.
In earlier models, there was nothing but your weight on the saddle stopping the rear end tucking under, which was an issue if you picked up the unfolded bike (or bunny hopped itā¦). Now thereās a catch to hold the rear triangle in place.
The top of the rear triangle has a rubber suspension bumper where it butts against the seat tube. There are two grades of suspension available: standard or firm. Unless youāre very light, pick firm. If itās too soft, the suspension bobs through each crank revolution, robbing a little energy and making the bike wallow.
Tucking the rear wheel under is step one of the folding procedure. Step two, once youāve ensured the left-hand crank points forward, is to undo the frame hinge and, holding the stem, lift the front end of the bike up and back; a catch on the left-hand fork blade hooks over the drive-side chain stay.
Step three is to undo the seatpost quick release, lower the seatpost, then refasten the quick release; the dropped seatpost locks the rear triangle into its folded position. Step four is to undo the stem hinge and let the stem and handlebar drop down; a nodule on the stem fits into a bracket on the fork crown, holding the stem and bar in place.
Finally, rotate the cranks backwards so that the right-hand pedal is next to the tyre, and then fold the left-hand pedal. You can now pick up the bike by the saddle nose or main frame tube, or on smooth surfaces roll it on its castors ā something thatās easier with the handlebar left unfolded.
Written down, this sounds fairly involved. In practice, it becomes second nature and youāll do it comfortably in 10-15 seconds. It takes about the same amount of time to unfold, despite the fact that the hinges arenāt self-locking.
With a standard seatpost, Iām fortuitously the ideal height (1.77m) and can just raise it to its maximum extension. As the test bike had the longer āextendedā seatpost, I had to faff with saddle height like everyone else, and I sorely missed the height markers of the Birdyās seatpost.
The speed of folding/unfolding is useful for commuting, where youāll be doing it multiple times on any mixed-mode journey. It also means you can avoid carrying the bike more than you absolutely have to. Better to push it along the platform, or drag it on its castors, than heft it.
At 11kg, the S2L is no heavyweight (in fact, itās 1.4kg lighter than my old 3-speed Brompton), but itās difficult to walk any distance with ā and I say that as a fit and healthy, average-sized bloke. Slightly built owners will struggle. A shoulder strap would be a useful accessory.
The frame has fittings for mudguards, which donāt affect the fold, and dedicated racks front and rear. The front luggage system is excellent, with a choice of bags to fit the optional mount on the head tube. The Brompton rear rack is largely superfluous, mostly adding weight plus some stability to the folded bike. There arenāt any bottle mounts.
While the frame is a marvel of metallurgical origami, there are a couple of things Iād change. One is the fact that the rear mudguard sits on top the chain stay brace. Since this gets hosed with water, it eventually rusts away ā unless you choose the āSuperlightā titanium option. The second thing is the fork offset: thereās too much. More on that later.
## Frame and folding: Birdy
Unlike the Brompton, the Birdy is aluminium rather than steel and thereās no hinge in the main frame, so it canāt flex there. Stronger and heavier riders will appreciate this. Without a frame hinge, it canāt fold as compactly either, but the folding process is still ingenious.
First, you need to put it into top gear (otherwise the chain will fall off when you fold the bike). Second, level the cranks with the left one forward. Third, lift the front end off the ground, unclip the front wheel at its suspension elastomer, and then fold the wheel back on itself, rotating it around its own suspension pivots.
Fourth, unclip the rear wheel and tuck it under, similar to the Brompton. Fifth, lower the seatpost to lock the rear swing-arm in position. Finally, undo and fold down the handlebar.
The Birdy evidently holds the record for the fastest fold, at 4.9 seconds, but Iāve never got anywhere near this and it always took me longer to fold than the Brompton. It felt like more hassle too, perhaps due to a lack of familiarity. So I didnāt fold the Birdy when I didnāt have to. With the Brompton, it is no bother: you fold it without thinking.
I encountered a couple of snags folding the Birdy. The handlebar wouldnāt fold flush, as the grip overlapped the quick release lever. This might be solved by: narrower rear dropouts; removing the kickstand (youāll need a spacer instead); and/or having Allen-headed wheel bolts instead of a quick release with a cam lever.
You also need to take care to keep the rear derailleur out of the front wheel when folding. Thereās little space between them.
When itās folded, the Birdy isnāt any harder to carry than the Brompton. Itās just bulkier. It will easily fit an end-of-carriage luggage rack, but getting it from one end of a busy train carriage to the other is awkward. I collided with knees, elbows, newspapers and tempers.
Unfolded, the Birdy benefits from elastomer suspension front and rear ā 30mm and 40mm respectively. The rear is a bumper for the swing-arm, like the Bromptonās. The front is part of an unusual-looking leading link fork. This tracks well and doesnāt dive during braking. For my weight (65kg), the standard elastomers were fine. If I were to change them, Iād fit the firm ones but soft is also an option.
The World Sport comes with a kickstand (whose rubber foot fell off) and mudguards with sturdy stays. They need to be strong as the folded bike rests on these mudguards. A low-rider front rack and a cantilevered rear rack are available as extras, although Iād fit a large Carradice SQR block and a Super C Saddlebag instead. As with the Brompton, there are no bottle mounts.
## Ride
The Brompton has very quick steering due to its tiny amount of trail. Some will characterise this as ānippyā, others ānervousā. With both hands on the handlebar, the handling is OK. Signalling requires concentration, especially when youāre descending or the road surface is rough.
If you use one of Bromptonās excellent front bags, the extra weight over the front wheel makes the steering less skittish, although even without a front bag itās not so unusual that you canāt get used it. Yet Iām sure the handling could be much improved by reducing the forkās offset to zero. This might necessitate other design tweaks to prevent compromising the fold.
The S-bar provides a sportier riding position than the M-bar Iām used to. I liked it. You end up with more weight on your hands, so for comfort Iād recommend bar ends (up to about 80-90mm wonāt interfere with the fold) or flared, ergonomic grips; Ergon GP3 grips would address both issues. Schwalbeās Kojak tyres are a good match for the S-bar, helping these small wheels hold their speed better.
Nippy around town is one thing; if youāre going further, the Brompton is seldom the best choice. While some owners tour on Bromptons, and Iāve done 50-mile rides on mine, single-digit mileages are what this bike does best. Consequently, I think fewer gears (and less weight to carry) is the better choice.
The Birdy rides less like a folder and more like a conventional bike. The handling is stable because itās got more trail, so you can tackle descents and everyday manoeuvres with greater confidence. As the reach is roomier, youāll feel less perched on it if youāre taller than average. The unusually high bottom bracket suits longer-legged riders too.
The simple elastomer suspension front and rear goes a long way to offsetting the issues that small wheels have compared to large ones. It removes the āchatterā you get from anything other than a billiard table smooth road.
Itās more comfortable, since the bike absorbs small bumps before you do. It also improves the rolling performance, because the wheels flow over bumps rather than being buffeted or baulked by them.
Iād have no hesitation in doing all-day rides on a Birdy, with or without luggage. Like any bike with suspension you canāt lock out, it rides best if you sit and spin; riding it out of the saddle is like running on a trampoline.
## Components
Convoluted cable runs can affect the braking performance of any folder that uses mechanical callipers. Happily, the Bromptonās long-reach sidepulls are better than they were in the past. Theyāre now dual pivots, fitted with decent Fibrax blocks, and the all-metal levers are less spongy. I had no problems scrubbing off speed.
The callipers lack quick releases, so you need to deflate the tyre to get the wheel out or in, which is odd.
The Birdy uses V-brakes, which are more powerful ā just as well given the higher speeds you can comfortably reach on this bike. The pads arenāt perpendicular to the brake arms, particularly at the rear, so watch for uneven pad wear. Parallel-push V-brakes would be a solution but Iām not aware of anywhere you can get them, other than eBay.
The Bromptonās two-speed gearing is fine around town: you get one gear for starting off or climbing modest hills and another for cruising along. Both are a little high, so consider one of the gear reduction options (7% or 18%) at point of purchase.
The shifter, which indicates the gear with a + or a ā, turns the Brompton chain tensioner into a derailleur by moving the top jockey wheel. Itās not as slick as Shimano, especially shifting against the spring (down), but it works OK.
The Birdy uses an 8-speed twistgrip and a Shimano Claris derailleur thatās unremarkable except for the long chain guide projecting from the bottom. This is for the loose chain to hang on when the rear wheel tucks under. Claris will cope with a 32 sprocket, so itās a shame an 11-30 cassette is fitted.
Bottom gear is a bit high for the day rides or tours this bike is capable of. Iād be tempted to try an 11-34 cassette, using a longer B-screw to nudge the derailleur away from this bigger cassette.
Small wheels need efficient tyres to roll as well as big ones, and both these bikes have them. The Birdy has Schwalbe Marathon Racer tyres, which are a big improvement from the stodgy Impac Streetpacs that I criticised the World Sport for last time I tested one.
The Brompton, meanwhile, has Schwalbe Kojak tyres because I asked for them. You can choose between Kojaks, Schwalbe Marathons and Brompton Kevlar tyres when you use Bromptonās online ābike builderā.
> The Birdy rides less like a folder and more like a conventional bikeā¦ Iād not hesitate to do all-day rides on it. I didnāt fold the Birdy when I didnāt have to. With the Brompton, it is no bother: you fold it without thinking
>
> Dan Joyce, Cycle magazine editor
## Verdict
It boils down to what you want most: a fantastic folder that rides OK, or a small-wheeler that rides really well and folds OK. The Brompton is the better mixed-mode commuter because of its more compact fold, whereas the Birdyās superior ride makes it the better choice for mixed-mode journeys you want to enjoy, such as touring and leisure riding.
The Birdy is arguably more versatile too, being a more capable commuter than the Brompton is a tourer. But versatility isnāt everything.
The Brompton fills one role exceptionally well: short-distance utility transport that blends into the background when you donāt need it as a bike. Thatās all I really need a folder for, so Iāll probably replace my 16-year-old Brompton with a newer version when the time comes.
Your mileage, as ever, may vary. If you have the chance to test ride and test fold both bikes, take it.
### First published in Cycle magazine, August/September 2017 issue. All information correct at time of publishing.
[Cycle magazine](https://www.cyclinguk.org/tags/cycle-magazine "Cycle magazine") [Commuting](https://www.cyclinguk.org/tags/commuting "Commuting") [Commuter bike](https://www.cyclinguk.org/tags/commuter-bike "Commuter bike") [Folding bike](https://www.cyclinguk.org/tags/folding-bike "Folding bike") [Bike reviews](https://www.cyclinguk.org/tags/bike-reviews "Bike reviews") [Bikes and cycling kit](https://www.cyclinguk.org/tags/bikes-and-cycling-kit "Bikes and cycling kit") [Tests and reviews](https://www.cyclinguk.org/tags/tests-and-reviews "Tests and reviews")
## Our test promise
At Cycling UK and Cycle magazine, we are proudly independent. Thereās no pressure to please advertisers as weāre funded by our members. Our product reviews arenāt press releases; theyāre written by experienced cyclists after thorough testing.
## Tech specs
### [Brompton S2L](https://www.brompton.com/Buy/Bikes)
**Price:** Ā£970 as tested
**Sizes:** one size
**Weight:** 10.97kg (as pictured)
**Folded size:** 58.5Ć56.5Ć27cm (claimed); 67.5Ć61Ć29cm (measured)
**Frame & Fork:** Steel frame, fork and rear triangle, with firm suspension block. Fittings for mudguards, rear rack, front carrier
**Wheels:** 32-349 Schwalbe Kojak tyres, 17Ć349 aluminium rims, Brompton hubs, 28 radial pg spokes (f), 28Ć2 butted (rear)
**Transmission:** Brompton pedals (left, folding), 54t 170mm Brompton chainset, square taper FAG bottom bracket, Sram PC10 chain, 12-16t two-speed ācassetteā. Brompton 2-speed shifter and derailleur. 2 ratios, 55-74in
**Braking:** Brompton dual pivot callipers
**Steering & Seating:** Brompton foam grips, S-type handlebar (540Ć25.6mm), threaded headset. Brompton saddle, 600Ć32mm Brompton extended seatpost
**Equipment:** Brompton mudguards, front carrier block, pump, integral bell
### [Birdy World Sport](https://www.r-m.de/en-fi/bikes/birdy/)
**Price:** Ā£1,169
**Sizes:** one size
**Weight:** 11.4kg as pictured
**Folded size:** 80Ć62Ć34cm (claimed); 93Ć69Ć40cm (measured)
**Frame & Fork:** Aluminium frame, swing-arm and leading-link fork, with fittings for mudguards and racks. Standard suspension elastomers
**Wheels:** 40-355 Schwalbe Marathon Racer tyres, Alex Crostini 1.1 18in rims, 24 radial (f) and 32Ć2 (r) 2.0 Sapim spokes, Birdy front hub, Shimano Alivio rear hub
**Transmission:** VP-191 pedals, 170mm 56t Sunrace chainset, square taper bottom bracket, KMC X8 chain, Shimano HG51 8-speed 11-30 cassette. Shimano Revoshift shifter, Shimano Claris derailleur. 8 ratios, 32-88in
**Braking:** Avid Single Digit V-brakes with Tektro levers
**Steering & Seating**: Velo grips, 31.8Ć540mm handlebar, Birdy Sport 21Ā° adjustable-height stem, threadless headset. Birdy saddle, 34.9Ć565mm aluminium seatpost
**Equipment:** SKS World Birdy mudguards, kickstand, bell
## Other options
### [Airnimal Rhino Road](https://airnimal.co/) Ā£2,299
Unlike other Airnimals, the Rhino has 20in wheels so should go on UK trains without arguments. Can pack small but āfirst foldā is bulky. Carbon fork, 3Ć9 Tiagra gearing, Avid BB7s, RockShox Monarch shock, 11.5kg.
### [Tern Verge N8](http://ternbicycles.com/uk/bikes/473/verge-n8) Ā£825
Folds quickly and simply to 38Ć79Ć72cm and weighs 11kg, so easily train portable. Uses 1Ć8 Shimano Claris gearing, V-brakes, and 20in wheels shod with 35-406 Schwalbe Kojak tyres. Mudguards included.
### Further reading
- [ On my bike: John Grimshaw View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-magazine/my-bike-john-grimshaw "On my bike: John Grimshaw")
- [ Bike test: Folding e-bikes View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-magazine/bike-test-folding-e-bikes "Bike test: Folding e-bikes")
- [ Bike test: Brompton T-Line One View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-magazine/bike-test-brompton-t-line-one "Bike test: Brompton T-Line One")
- [ Group test: Brompton bags for commuting View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/article/group-test-brompton-bags-commuting "Group test: Brompton bags for commuting")
- [ Bike test: Less famous folding bicycles View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-magazine/bike-test-less-famous-folding-bicycles "Bike test: Less famous folding bicycles")
- [ On my bike: Dr Ronx Ikharia View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-magazine/my-bike-dr-ronx-ikharia "On my bike: Dr Ronx Ikharia")
- [ Bike test: Tern Link B7 folding bike View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-magazine/bike-test-tern-link-b7-folding-bike "Bike test: Tern Link B7 folding bike")
- [ Great Rides: Folders go Forth in Scotland View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-magazine/great-rides-folders-go-forth-scotland "Great Rides: Folders go Forth in Scotland")
- [ Bike test: Brompton Electric folding e-cycle View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-magazine/bike-test-brompton-electric-folding-e-cycle "Bike test: Brompton Electric folding e-cycle")
- [ My Bike: Ned Boulting's Brompton View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/article/my-bike-ned-boultings-brompton "My Bike: Ned Boulting's Brompton")
- [ Chief Executive "stunnedā after kind-hearted Samaritan returns bike stolen from a train View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/press-release/chief-executive-stunned-after-kind-hearted-samaritan-returns-bike-stolen-train "Chief Executive \"stunnedā after kind-hearted Samaritan returns bike stolen from a train")
- [ Cycle Magazine, August / September 2017 View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/publication/cycle-magazine/august-2017 "Cycle Magazine, August / September 2017")
- [ Bromptons up the Alps View](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle/bromptons-alps "Bromptons up the Alps")
### Subscribe to Cycling UK
President: Jon Snow
Chief Executive: Sarah Mitchell
Cycling UK is a trading name of Cyclists' Touring Club (CTC) a company limited by guarantee, registered in England no: 25185. Registered as a charity in England and Wales charity no: 1147607 and in Scotland charity no: SC042541. Registered office: Parklands, Railton Road, Guildford, Surrey GU2 9JX.
**Copyright Ā© CTC 2026**
- [Shop](https://shop.cyclinguk.org/ "Shop")
- [Jobs](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycling-uk-jobs "Jobs")
- [Volunteering](https://app.goassemble.com/auth/login "Volunteer")
- [Forum](https://forum.cyclinguk.org/ "Forum")
- [Press office](https://www.cyclinguk.org/contact/press-and-media "Press office")
- [Our policies, terms and conditions](https://www.cyclinguk.org/policies-terms-conditions "Our policies, terms and conditions")
- [Contact us](https://www.cyclinguk.org/contact "Contact")
- Routes
- [Routes](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes "Routes")
- [Planning your route](https://www.cyclinguk.org/journey-planner "Planning your route")
- [All GPX routes](https://www.cyclinguk.org/all-our-cycling-routes)
- [Our Adventure Series](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/adventure-series "Adventure Series")
- [Royal Chilterns Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/royal-chilterns-way "Royal Chilterns Way")
- [Marcher Castles Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/marcher-castles-way "Marcher Castles Way")
- [Traws Eryri](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/traws-eryri "Traws Eryri")
- [Rebellion Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/rebellion-way "Rebellion Way")
- [Cantii Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/cantii-way "Cantii Way")
- [West Kernow Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/west-kernow-way "West Kernow Way")
- [King Alfredās Way](https://www.cyclinguk.org/routes/long-distance/king-alfreds-way "King Alfredās Way")
- [Help fund our next cycle route](https://www.cyclinguk.org/long-distance-routes-appeal)
- Go cycling
- [All advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/advice "All advice")
- [Beginner advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/advice/beginner-cycling "Beginner advice")
- [Cycling as a family](https://www.cyclinguk.org/advice/cycling-family "Cycling as a family")
- [Different types of cycling](https://www.cyclinguk.org/advice/type-cycling "Different types of cycling ")
- [Bikes, cycles and kit](https://www.cyclinguk.org/bikes-cycles-and-kit "Bikes, cycles and kit")
- [Seasonal advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/seasonal-advice "Seasonal advice")
- [Safety advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-safety-advice "Safety advice ")
- [Maintenance advice](https://www.cyclinguk.org/essential-cycle-maintenance-advice "Maintenance advice")
- [Clubs and groups](https://www.cyclinguk.org/local-groups "Ride together (clubs and groups)")
- [Events](https://www.cyclinguk.org/special-events "Events")
- Campaigning
- [Our campaigns](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns "Our campaigns")
- [Local cycle campaigning](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/cycle-advocacy-network "Cycle Advocacy Network")
- [Cyclists' Defence Fund](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/cyclists-defence-fund "Cyclists' Defence Fund")
- [Sign up for updates](https://www.cyclinguk.org/subscribe-cycling-uk "Sign up for updates")
- [Cycling UK statistics](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/statistics "Cycling UK statistics")
- [Cycling UK views and briefings](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-campaigning/briefings "Cycling UK views and briefings ")
- [My ride. Our right](https://www.cyclinguk.org/my-ride-our-right)
- [Scotland election 2026](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/elections-2026/scotland)
- [Wales Senedd election 2026](https://www.cyclinguk.org/campaigns/elections-2026/wales)
- Make a difference
- [Become a member](https://www.cyclinguk.org/join-cycling-uk-today "Become a member")
- [Give a gift membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/gift-membership "Give a gift membership")
- [Group membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/join-group "Group membership")
- [Cycle Activity Provider membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle-activity-provider-membership "Cycle Activity Provider membership")
- [Ways of giving](https://www.cyclinguk.org/make-a-difference/giving "Ways of giving")
- [Fundraising](https://www.cyclinguk.org/make-a-difference/fundraising)
- [Lottery and raffle](https://www.cyclinguk.org/make-a-difference/win)
- [Corporate partnerships](https://www.cyclinguk.org/corporate-partners "Corporate partnerships")
- [Join the conversation](https://www.cyclinguk.org/join-conversation "Join the conversation")
- [Volunteer](https://www.cyclinguk.org/volunteer "Volunteer")
- Services
- [Insurance](https://www.cyclinguk.org/insurance "Insurance")
- [Incident Line](https://www.cyclinguk.org/member-benefits/cycling-uk-incident-line "Incident Line")
- [Workplaces](https://www.cyclinguk.org/workplaces "Support for workplaces")
- [Cycle Friendly Employer](https://www.cyclinguk.org/workplaces/cycle-friendly-employer "Cycle Friendly Employer")
- [Cycle Friendly Building](https://www.cyclinguk.org/workplaces/cycle-friendly-building)
- [Employee membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/workplaces/employee-membership "Employer membership")
- [Courses](https://www.cyclinguk.org/courses-and-training/courses-available "Courses")
- [Organising events](https://www.cyclinguk.org/ride-and-event-organiser-insurance "Organising events")
- [Cycle magazine](https://www.cyclinguk.org/publications/cycle "Cycle magazine")
- [Support for clubs and groups](https://www.cyclinguk.org/local-groups "Support for clubs and groups")
- [Consultancy and advisory services](https://www.cyclinguk.org/consultancy-and-advisory-services)
- Our charity
- [Who we are](https://www.cyclinguk.org/about "Who we are")
- [Our projects](https://www.cyclinguk.org/community-cycling-projects "Our projects")
- [Contact us](https://www.cyclinguk.org/contact "Contact us")
- [Jobs](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycling-uk-jobs "Jobs")
- [Publications](https://www.cyclinguk.org/publications)
- [News, blogs and features](https://www.cyclinguk.org/news-blogs-features-and-articles "News, blogs and features")
- [Cycling UK in England](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycling-uk-england "Cycling UK in England")
- [Cycling UK in Scotland](https://www.cyclinguk.org/scotland "Cycling UK in Scotland")
- [Cycling UK in Northern Ireland](https://www.cyclinguk.org/northern-ireland "Cycling UK in Northern Ireland")
- [Cycling UK in Wales](https://www.cyclinguk.org/wales "Cycling UK in Wales")
- [Our strategy to 2029](https://www.cyclinguk.org/strategy "Our strategy to 2029")
- [Cycling UK shop](https://www.cyclinguk.org/shop "Cycling UK shop")
- Search
- [Donate](https://www.cyclinguk.org/cycle/bike-test-compact-folding-bikes?form=general-donation "Donate")
- [Membership](https://www.cyclinguk.org/join-cycling-uk-today "Membership")
- [Log in](https://www.cyclinguk.org/user/login "Log in")
- [Logout](https://www.cyclinguk.org/user/logout "Logout")
- [Search](https://www.cyclinguk.org/site-search "Search")
- Accessibility |
| Readable Markdown | Trains, buses, car boots, boats, aeroplanes, offices, cloakrooms, hallways, studio flats ā folding bikes go where others wonāt fit or arenāt freely allowed. The smaller they pack down, the more loopholes theyāll slip through. For example, trains in the UK carry ācompact, fully folding cycles with wheels up to 20" in diameterā¦ without restrictionā.
Two of the best compacts are the Brompton and the Birdy. Both cost from around Ā£1,000, which is a lot more than an entry-level Dahon (rebadged or otherwise). Yet for long-term usage, itās money well spent.
A compact folder enables you to integrate cycling into your everyday life so deeply that it may transform the way you think about transport. Moreover, the initial cost will be recouped in saved bus or taxi fares or petrol.
In its 40-year history, the Brompton has evolved from a bike-rail solution for the cognoscenti into a marketing-friendly, middle-class icon. It now exists in a variety of Ć la carte formats.
I picked a 2-speed partly because Iāve not used the Brompton derailleur before, but also because it saves about 600g over the 3-speed, and low weight is a big deal for a bike youāll often hold in one hand. With mudguards, flat S-type handlebar, Schwalbe Kojak tyres, and the all-important front luggage block, it costs Ā£970.
The German Birdy is even more premium priced than the Brompton; standard models start at Ā£2,069. However, manufacturer Riese und MĆ¼ller also offers a couple of āmodel-T Fordā versions: the World Birdy Comfort (Ā£1,439 with Nexus 8-speed hub, dynamo lights, and rear rack); and the Ā£1,169 World Birdy Sport, which comes with 8-speed derailleur gearing and in any colour you like as long as itās black.
(Note that in common with UK retailers, Iām transposing the name and calling this bike the Birdy World Sport.)
## Frame and folding: Brompton
One of the reasons that the Brompton is so compact is that it doesnāt simply fold in half. The rear triangle pivots behind the bottom bracket, enabling the rear wheel to tuck underneath the main frame tube. The bike stays upright sitting on its haunches, so it can be parked like this.
In earlier models, there was nothing but your weight on the saddle stopping the rear end tucking under, which was an issue if you picked up the unfolded bike (or bunny hopped itā¦). Now thereās a catch to hold the rear triangle in place.
The top of the rear triangle has a rubber suspension bumper where it butts against the seat tube. There are two grades of suspension available: standard or firm. Unless youāre very light, pick firm. If itās too soft, the suspension bobs through each crank revolution, robbing a little energy and making the bike wallow.
Tucking the rear wheel under is step one of the folding procedure. Step two, once youāve ensured the left-hand crank points forward, is to undo the frame hinge and, holding the stem, lift the front end of the bike up and back; a catch on the left-hand fork blade hooks over the drive-side chain stay.
Step three is to undo the seatpost quick release, lower the seatpost, then refasten the quick release; the dropped seatpost locks the rear triangle into its folded position. Step four is to undo the stem hinge and let the stem and handlebar drop down; a nodule on the stem fits into a bracket on the fork crown, holding the stem and bar in place.
Finally, rotate the cranks backwards so that the right-hand pedal is next to the tyre, and then fold the left-hand pedal. You can now pick up the bike by the saddle nose or main frame tube, or on smooth surfaces roll it on its castors ā something thatās easier with the handlebar left unfolded.
Written down, this sounds fairly involved. In practice, it becomes second nature and youāll do it comfortably in 10-15 seconds. It takes about the same amount of time to unfold, despite the fact that the hinges arenāt self-locking.
With a standard seatpost, Iām fortuitously the ideal height (1.77m) and can just raise it to its maximum extension. As the test bike had the longer āextendedā seatpost, I had to faff with saddle height like everyone else, and I sorely missed the height markers of the Birdyās seatpost.
The speed of folding/unfolding is useful for commuting, where youāll be doing it multiple times on any mixed-mode journey. It also means you can avoid carrying the bike more than you absolutely have to. Better to push it along the platform, or drag it on its castors, than heft it.
At 11kg, the S2L is no heavyweight (in fact, itās 1.4kg lighter than my old 3-speed Brompton), but itās difficult to walk any distance with ā and I say that as a fit and healthy, average-sized bloke. Slightly built owners will struggle. A shoulder strap would be a useful accessory.
The frame has fittings for mudguards, which donāt affect the fold, and dedicated racks front and rear. The front luggage system is excellent, with a choice of bags to fit the optional mount on the head tube. The Brompton rear rack is largely superfluous, mostly adding weight plus some stability to the folded bike. There arenāt any bottle mounts.
While the frame is a marvel of metallurgical origami, there are a couple of things Iād change. One is the fact that the rear mudguard sits on top the chain stay brace. Since this gets hosed with water, it eventually rusts away ā unless you choose the āSuperlightā titanium option. The second thing is the fork offset: thereās too much. More on that later.
## Frame and folding: Birdy
Unlike the Brompton, the Birdy is aluminium rather than steel and thereās no hinge in the main frame, so it canāt flex there. Stronger and heavier riders will appreciate this. Without a frame hinge, it canāt fold as compactly either, but the folding process is still ingenious.
First, you need to put it into top gear (otherwise the chain will fall off when you fold the bike). Second, level the cranks with the left one forward. Third, lift the front end off the ground, unclip the front wheel at its suspension elastomer, and then fold the wheel back on itself, rotating it around its own suspension pivots.
Fourth, unclip the rear wheel and tuck it under, similar to the Brompton. Fifth, lower the seatpost to lock the rear swing-arm in position. Finally, undo and fold down the handlebar.
The Birdy evidently holds the record for the fastest fold, at 4.9 seconds, but Iāve never got anywhere near this and it always took me longer to fold than the Brompton. It felt like more hassle too, perhaps due to a lack of familiarity. So I didnāt fold the Birdy when I didnāt have to. With the Brompton, it is no bother: you fold it without thinking.
I encountered a couple of snags folding the Birdy. The handlebar wouldnāt fold flush, as the grip overlapped the quick release lever. This might be solved by: narrower rear dropouts; removing the kickstand (youāll need a spacer instead); and/or having Allen-headed wheel bolts instead of a quick release with a cam lever.
You also need to take care to keep the rear derailleur out of the front wheel when folding. Thereās little space between them.
When itās folded, the Birdy isnāt any harder to carry than the Brompton. Itās just bulkier. It will easily fit an end-of-carriage luggage rack, but getting it from one end of a busy train carriage to the other is awkward. I collided with knees, elbows, newspapers and tempers.
Unfolded, the Birdy benefits from elastomer suspension front and rear ā 30mm and 40mm respectively. The rear is a bumper for the swing-arm, like the Bromptonās. The front is part of an unusual-looking leading link fork. This tracks well and doesnāt dive during braking. For my weight (65kg), the standard elastomers were fine. If I were to change them, Iād fit the firm ones but soft is also an option.
The World Sport comes with a kickstand (whose rubber foot fell off) and mudguards with sturdy stays. They need to be strong as the folded bike rests on these mudguards. A low-rider front rack and a cantilevered rear rack are available as extras, although Iād fit a large Carradice SQR block and a Super C Saddlebag instead. As with the Brompton, there are no bottle mounts.
## Ride
The Brompton has very quick steering due to its tiny amount of trail. Some will characterise this as ānippyā, others ānervousā. With both hands on the handlebar, the handling is OK. Signalling requires concentration, especially when youāre descending or the road surface is rough.
If you use one of Bromptonās excellent front bags, the extra weight over the front wheel makes the steering less skittish, although even without a front bag itās not so unusual that you canāt get used it. Yet Iām sure the handling could be much improved by reducing the forkās offset to zero. This might necessitate other design tweaks to prevent compromising the fold.
The S-bar provides a sportier riding position than the M-bar Iām used to. I liked it. You end up with more weight on your hands, so for comfort Iād recommend bar ends (up to about 80-90mm wonāt interfere with the fold) or flared, ergonomic grips; Ergon GP3 grips would address both issues. Schwalbeās Kojak tyres are a good match for the S-bar, helping these small wheels hold their speed better.
Nippy around town is one thing; if youāre going further, the Brompton is seldom the best choice. While some owners tour on Bromptons, and Iāve done 50-mile rides on mine, single-digit mileages are what this bike does best. Consequently, I think fewer gears (and less weight to carry) is the better choice.
The Birdy rides less like a folder and more like a conventional bike. The handling is stable because itās got more trail, so you can tackle descents and everyday manoeuvres with greater confidence. As the reach is roomier, youāll feel less perched on it if youāre taller than average. The unusually high bottom bracket suits longer-legged riders too.
The simple elastomer suspension front and rear goes a long way to offsetting the issues that small wheels have compared to large ones. It removes the āchatterā you get from anything other than a billiard table smooth road.
Itās more comfortable, since the bike absorbs small bumps before you do. It also improves the rolling performance, because the wheels flow over bumps rather than being buffeted or baulked by them.
Iād have no hesitation in doing all-day rides on a Birdy, with or without luggage. Like any bike with suspension you canāt lock out, it rides best if you sit and spin; riding it out of the saddle is like running on a trampoline.
## Components
Convoluted cable runs can affect the braking performance of any folder that uses mechanical callipers. Happily, the Bromptonās long-reach sidepulls are better than they were in the past. Theyāre now dual pivots, fitted with decent Fibrax blocks, and the all-metal levers are less spongy. I had no problems scrubbing off speed.
The callipers lack quick releases, so you need to deflate the tyre to get the wheel out or in, which is odd.
The Birdy uses V-brakes, which are more powerful ā just as well given the higher speeds you can comfortably reach on this bike. The pads arenāt perpendicular to the brake arms, particularly at the rear, so watch for uneven pad wear. Parallel-push V-brakes would be a solution but Iām not aware of anywhere you can get them, other than eBay.
The Bromptonās two-speed gearing is fine around town: you get one gear for starting off or climbing modest hills and another for cruising along. Both are a little high, so consider one of the gear reduction options (7% or 18%) at point of purchase.
The shifter, which indicates the gear with a + or a ā, turns the Brompton chain tensioner into a derailleur by moving the top jockey wheel. Itās not as slick as Shimano, especially shifting against the spring (down), but it works OK.
The Birdy uses an 8-speed twistgrip and a Shimano Claris derailleur thatās unremarkable except for the long chain guide projecting from the bottom. This is for the loose chain to hang on when the rear wheel tucks under. Claris will cope with a 32 sprocket, so itās a shame an 11-30 cassette is fitted.
Bottom gear is a bit high for the day rides or tours this bike is capable of. Iād be tempted to try an 11-34 cassette, using a longer B-screw to nudge the derailleur away from this bigger cassette.
Small wheels need efficient tyres to roll as well as big ones, and both these bikes have them. The Birdy has Schwalbe Marathon Racer tyres, which are a big improvement from the stodgy Impac Streetpacs that I criticised the World Sport for last time I tested one.
The Brompton, meanwhile, has Schwalbe Kojak tyres because I asked for them. You can choose between Kojaks, Schwalbe Marathons and Brompton Kevlar tyres when you use Bromptonās online ābike builderā.
> The Birdy rides less like a folder and more like a conventional bikeā¦ Iād not hesitate to do all-day rides on it. I didnāt fold the Birdy when I didnāt have to. With the Brompton, it is no bother: you fold it without thinking
>
> Dan Joyce, Cycle magazine editor
## Verdict
It boils down to what you want most: a fantastic folder that rides OK, or a small-wheeler that rides really well and folds OK. The Brompton is the better mixed-mode commuter because of its more compact fold, whereas the Birdyās superior ride makes it the better choice for mixed-mode journeys you want to enjoy, such as touring and leisure riding.
The Birdy is arguably more versatile too, being a more capable commuter than the Brompton is a tourer. But versatility isnāt everything.
The Brompton fills one role exceptionally well: short-distance utility transport that blends into the background when you donāt need it as a bike. Thatās all I really need a folder for, so Iāll probably replace my 16-year-old Brompton with a newer version when the time comes.
Your mileage, as ever, may vary. If you have the chance to test ride and test fold both bikes, take it.
### First published in Cycle magazine, August/September 2017 issue. All information correct at time of publishing. |
| Shard | 19 (laksa) |
| Root Hash | 4498110212279631819 |
| Unparsed URL | org,cyclinguk!www,/cycle/bike-test-compact-folding-bikes s443 |