ℹ️ Skipped - page is already crawled
| Filter | Status | Condition | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| HTTP status | PASS | download_http_code = 200 | HTTP 200 |
| Age cutoff | PASS | download_stamp > now() - 6 MONTH | 3.5 months ago |
| History drop | PASS | isNull(history_drop_reason) | No drop reason |
| Spam/ban | PASS | fh_dont_index != 1 AND ml_spam_score = 0 | ml_spam_score=0 |
| Canonical | PASS | meta_canonical IS NULL OR = '' OR = src_unparsed | Not set |
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| URL | https://fair.org/extra/kal-007-and-iran-air-655/ |
| Last Crawled | 2025-12-29 00:55:46 (3 months ago) |
| First Indexed | 2019-11-10 04:35:50 (6 years ago) |
| HTTP Status Code | 200 |
| Meta Title | KAL 007 and Iran Air 655: Comparing the Coverage — FAIR |
| Meta Description | null |
| Meta Canonical | null |
| Boilerpipe Text | The USS Vincennes firing a missile similar to the one the warship used to kill 290 people on board Iran Air 655. The day after a Soviet interceptor plane blew up a Korean passenger jet, the first sentence of a New York Times editorial (9/2/83) was unequivocal: “There is no conceivable excuse for any nation shooting down a harmless airliner.” Headlined “Murder in the Air,” the editorial asserted that “no circumstance whatever justifies attacking an innocent plane.” Confronted with the sudden reality of a similar action by the U.S. government, the New York Times inverted every standard invoked with righteous indignation five years earlier. Editorials condemning the KAL shoot down were filled with phrases like “wanton killing,” “reckless aerial murder” and “no conceivable excuse.” But when Iran Air’s flight 655 was blown out of the sky on July 3, excuses were more than conceivable—they were profuse. Two days after the Iranian passenger jet went down in flames, killing 290 people, the Times (7/5/88) editorialized that “while horrifying, it was nonetheless an accident.” The editorial concluded, “The onus for avoiding such accidents in the future rests on civilian aircraft: avoid combat zones, fly high, acknowledge warnings.” A similar pattern pervaded electronic media coverage. In the aftermath of the KAL incident, America’s airwaves routinely carried journalistic denunciations. CBS anchor Dan Rather, for example, called it a “barbaric act.” No such adjectives were heard from America’s TV commentators when discussing the U.S. shootdown of a civilian jet. As soon as the Iranian Airbus crashed into the Persian Gulf, the Reagan administration set out to discourage what should have been obvious comparisons between the Soviet Union’s tragic mistake and our tragic mistake. The New York Times and other media uncritically quoted the president’s July 4 resurrection of his administration’s timeworn deceit: “Remember the KAL, a group of Soviet fighter planes went up, identified the plane for what it was and then proceeded to shoot it down. There’s no comparison.” Virtually ignored was a key finding of Seymour Hersh’s 1986 book The Target Is Destroyed —that the Reagan administration knew within days of the KAL shootdown that the Soviets had believed it to be a military aircraft on a spy mission. Soviet commanders had no idea that they were tracking a plane with civilians on board. The Times had acknowledged this long after the fact in an editorial, “The Lie That Wasn’t Shot Down” (1/18/88); yet when Reagan lied again, they failed again to shoot it down. Instead, Times correspondent R.W. Apple, Jr. (7/5/88) weighed in with an analysis headlined, “Military Errors: The Snafu as History”. In his lead, Apple observed that “the destruction of an Iranian airliner…came as a sharp reminder of the pervasive role of error in military history.” The piece drew many parallels to the Iran jetliner’s tragic end — citing examples from the American Revolution, World War II and Vietnam—while ignoring the most obvious analogy. About the KAL 007 shootdown, Apple said not a word. If anything, the recent tragedy was less defensible than the KAL disaster. The Iran Air jet went down in broad daylight, well within its approved commercial airline course over international waters, without ever having strayed into any unauthorized air space. In contrast, the Korean plane flew way off course, deep into Soviet territory above sensitive military installations, in the dead of night. But, as with Washington’s policy-makers, the mass media was intent on debunking relevant comparisons rather than exploring them. The government’s public relations spin quickly became the mass media’s: A tragic mishap had occurred in the Persian Gulf, amid puzzling behavior of the passenger jet. Blaming the victim was standard fare, as reporters focused on the plight of U.S.S. Vincennes commander Capt. Will Rodgers III, whose picture appeared on tabloid covers (7/5/88) with bold headlines: “Captain’s Anguish” ( Newsday ) and “Captain’s Agony” ( New York Post ). At the same time, U.S. journalists asserted that the Iranian government was eager to exploit its new propaganda advantage. Correspondent Tom Fenton informed viewers of the CBS Evening News (7/6/88) that Iran was intent on making sure the event would not slip from the world’s front pages; colleague Bert Quint followed up minutes later with a similar theme. Sorely lacking from the outset was any semblance of soul-searching about the holier-than-Moscow Soviet-bashing that followed the KAL accident. The last thing that White House officials wanted was any such national self-examination. But we might have hoped for more independence from the U.S. media, which allowed their proclaimed precepts to spin 180 degrees in an instant, while discarding basic insights like the one expressed in a New York Times editorial six days after KAL 007 exploded (9/7/83): “To proclaim a ‘right’ to shoot down suspicious planes does not make it right to do so.” FAIR’s work is sustained by our generous contributors, who allow us to remain independent. Donate today to be a part of this important mission. |
| Markdown | - [HOME](https://fair.org/)
- [ABOUT](https://fair.org/about-fair/)
- [DONATE](https://www.cambeywest.com/EXT/?f=donate)
- [COUNTERSPIN RADIO](https://fair.org/counterspin-radio)
- [EXTRA! NEWSLETTER](https://fair.org/extra/)
- [FAIR STUDIES](https://fair.org/study/)
- [ISSUES / TOPICS](https://fair.org/about-fair/topics-and-issues/)
- [STORE](https://www.cambeywest.com/subscribe2/?p=EXT&f=fairstore)
- [TAKE ACTION](https://fair.org/take-action)
FAIRNESS & ACCURACY IN REPORTING
Challenging media bias since 1986.
[ABOUT](https://fair.org/about-fair/)
- [Mission Statement](https://fair.org/about-fair/)
- [Staff, Associates & Board of Directors](https://fair.org/about-fair/staff-biographies/)
- [Contact FAIR](https://fair.org/contact-fair/)
- [Internship Program](https://fair.org/internship-program/)
- [What’s FAIR?](https://fair.org/home/whats-fair/)
- [What’s Wrong With the News?](https://fair.org/take-action-now/whats-wrong-with-the-news/)
- [FAIR’s Financial Overview](https://fair.org/public-support-fair-financial-overview/)
- [Privacy Policy](https://fair.org/about-fair/fair-privacy-policy/)
[DONATE](https://www.cambeywest.com/EXT/?f=appeal)
[COUNTERSPIN](https://fair.org/counterspin-radio)
- [Current Show](https://fair.org/home/kimberle-crenshaw-on-anti-blackness/)
- [Program Archives](https://fair.org/counterspin/)
- [Transcript Archives](https://fair.org/transcript/)
- [Get CounterSpin on Your Station](https://fair.org/about-counterspin/bringing-counterspin-to-your-station/)
- [Radio Station Finder](https://fair.org/counterspin-radio/#counterspin-radio-stations)
[EXTRA! NEWSLETTER](https://fair.org/extra-newsletter)
- [Subscribe to Extra\!](https://www.cambeywest.com/subscribe2/?p=EXT&f=paid)
- [Customer Care](https://www.cambeywest.com/EXT/?f=custserve)
[FAIR Studies](https://fair.org/study)
[ISSUES/TOPICS](https://fair.org/about-fair/topics-and-issues/)
[TAKE ACTION](https://fair.org/take-action)
- [FAIR’s Media Contact List](https://fair.org/take-action-now/media-contact-list/)
- [FAIR’s Resource List](https://fair.org/take-action-now/media-activism-kit/fairs-resource-list/)
[STORE](https://www.cambeywest.com/subscribe2/?p=EXT&f=fairstore)
- [HOME](https://fair.org/)
- [ABOUT](https://fair.org/about-fair/)
- [DONATE](https://www.cambeywest.com/EXT/?f=donate)
- [COUNTERSPIN RADIO](https://fair.org/counterspin-radio)
- [EXTRA! NEWSLETTER](https://fair.org/extra/)
- [FAIR STUDIES](https://fair.org/study/)
- [ISSUES / TOPICS](https://fair.org/about-fair/topics-and-issues/)
- [STORE](https://www.cambeywest.com/subscribe2/?p=EXT&f=fairstore)
- [TAKE ACTION](https://fair.org/take-action)
[FAIR](https://fair.org/)
FAIR is the national progressive media watchdog group, challenging corporate media bias, spin and misinformation.
Challenging media bias since 1986
▶ [ADVANCED SEARCH](https://fair.org/advanced-search/)
- [HOME](https://fair.org/)
- [ABOUT](https://fair.org/about-fair/)
- [About/Mission Statement](https://fair.org/about-fair/)
- [Staff, Associates & Board of Directors](https://fair.org/about-fair/staff-biographies/)
- [Contact FAIR](https://fair.org/contact-fair/)
- [Internship Program](https://fair.org/internship-program/)
- [Financial Overview](https://fair.org/public-support-fair-financial-overview/)
- [What’s FAIR?](https://fair.org/about-fair-media-watch/)
- [What’s Wrong With the News?](https://fair.org/about-fair/whats-wrong-with-the-news/)
- [DONATE](https://www.cambeywest.com/EXT/?f=donate)
- [Update Recurring Donation](https://www.cambeywest.com/EXT/?f=donprofile)
- [COUNTERSPIN RADIO](https://fair.org/counterspin-radio/)
- [About CounterSpin](https://fair.org/counterspin-radio/)
- [Program Archives](https://fair.org/counterspin/)
- [Transcript Archives](https://fair.org/transcript/)
- [Find a Station Near You\!](https://fair.org/listen-to-counterspin-on-your-local-radio-station/)
- [Get CounterSpin on Your Station](https://fair.org/about-counterspin/bringing-counterspin-to-your-station/)
- [EXTRA\!](https://fair.org/extra-newsletter/)
- [About Extra\!](https://fair.org/extra-newsletter/)
- [Subscribe to Extra\!](https://www.cambeywest.com/subscribe2/?p=EXT&f=paid)
- [Customer Care](https://www.cambeywest.com/EXT/?f=custserve)
- [FAIR STUDIES](https://fair.org/study/)
- [ISSUES / TOPICS](https://fair.org/about-fair/topics-and-issues/)
- [TAKE ACTION](https://fair.org/take-action/)
- [Action Alerts](https://fair.org/take-action/)
- [Activism Updates](https://fair.org/take-action/activism-updates/)
- [Join Our Email Network](https://fair.org/signup/)
- [FAIR’s Media Activism Kit](https://fair.org/take-action-now/media-activism-kit/)
- [FAIR’s Media Literacy Guide](https://fair.org/take-action-now/media-activism-kit/how-to-detect-bias-in-news-media/)
- [Organize\!](https://fair.org/take-action-now/media-activism-kit/organize/)
- [Media Contact List](https://fair.org/take-action-now/media-contact-list/)
- [Resource List](https://fair.org/take-action-now/media-activism-kit/fairs-resource-list/)
- [Recommended Reading](https://fair.org/take-action-now/media-activism-kit/recommended-reading/)
- [Media Activism Groups](https://fair.org/take-action-now/media-activism-kit/media-activism-groups-local-activists/)
- [EMAIL NETWORK](https://fair.org/signup/)
- [STORE](https://www.cambeywest.com/subscribe2/?p=EXT&f=fairstore)
- [CounterSpin Radio](https://fair.org/counterspin-radio/)
- [About CounterSpin](https://fair.org/counterspin-radio/)
- [Current Show](https://fair.org/home/kimberle-crenshaw-on-anti-blackness/)
- [Program Archives](https://fair.org/counterspin/)
- [Transcript Archives](https://fair.org/transcript/)
- [Get CounterSpin on Your Station](https://fair.org/about-counterspin/bringing-counterspin-to-your-station/)
- [Radio Station Finder](https://fair.org/counterspin-radio/#counterspin-radio-stations)
[](https://fair.org/extra/kal-007-and-iran-air-655/)
July 1, 1988
# KAL 007 and Iran Air 655
Comparing the Coverage
[FAIR](https://fair.org/author/woodglue/ "Posts by FAIR")
[](https://fair.org/extra/kal-007-and-iran-air-655/)
*The USS* Vincennes *firing a missile similar to the one the warship used to kill 290 people on board Iran Air 655.*
The day after a Soviet interceptor plane blew up a Korean passenger jet, the first sentence of a New York Times editorial (9/2/83) was unequivocal: “There is no conceivable excuse for any nation shooting down a harmless airliner.” Headlined “Murder in the Air,” the editorial asserted that “no circumstance whatever justifies attacking an innocent plane.”
Confronted with the sudden reality of a similar action by the U.S. government, the New York Times inverted every standard invoked with righteous indignation five years earlier. Editorials condemning the KAL shoot down were filled with phrases like “wanton killing,” “reckless aerial murder” and “no conceivable excuse.” But when Iran Air’s flight 655 was blown out of the sky on July 3, excuses were more than conceivable—they were profuse.
Two days after the Iranian passenger jet went down in flames, killing 290 people, the Times (7/5/88) editorialized that “while horrifying, it was nonetheless an accident.” The editorial concluded, “The onus for avoiding such accidents in the future rests on civilian aircraft: avoid combat zones, fly high, acknowledge warnings.”
A similar pattern pervaded electronic media coverage. In the aftermath of the KAL incident, America’s airwaves routinely carried journalistic denunciations. CBS anchor Dan Rather, for example, called it a “barbaric act.” No such adjectives were heard from America’s TV commentators when discussing the U.S. shootdown of a civilian jet.
**As soon as the Iranian Airbus** crashed into the Persian Gulf, the Reagan administration set out to discourage what should have been obvious comparisons between the Soviet Union’s tragic mistake and our tragic mistake. The New York Times and other media uncritically quoted the president’s July 4 resurrection of his administration’s timeworn deceit: “Remember the KAL, a group of Soviet fighter planes went up, identified the plane for what it was and then proceeded to shoot it down. There’s no comparison.”
Virtually ignored was a key finding of Seymour Hersh’s 1986 book *The Target Is Destroyed*—that the Reagan administration knew within days of the KAL shootdown that the Soviets had believed it to be a military aircraft on a spy mission. Soviet commanders had no idea that they were tracking a plane with civilians on board. The Times had acknowledged this long after the fact in an editorial, “The Lie That Wasn’t Shot Down” (1/18/88); yet when Reagan lied again, they failed again to shoot it down.
Instead, Times correspondent R.W. Apple, Jr. (7/5/88) weighed in with an analysis headlined, “Military Errors: The Snafu as History”. In his lead, Apple observed that “the destruction of an Iranian airliner…came as a sharp reminder of the pervasive role of error in military history.” The piece drew many parallels to the Iran jetliner’s tragic end — citing examples from the American Revolution, World War II and Vietnam—while ignoring the most obvious analogy. About the KAL 007 shootdown, Apple said not a word.
**If anything, the recent tragedy** was less defensible than the KAL disaster. The Iran Air jet went down in broad daylight, well within its approved commercial airline course over international waters, without ever having strayed into any unauthorized air space. In contrast, the Korean plane flew way off course, deep into Soviet territory above sensitive military installations, in the dead of night.
But, as with Washington’s policy-makers, the mass media was intent on debunking relevant comparisons rather than exploring them. The government’s public relations spin quickly became the mass media’s: A tragic mishap had occurred in the Persian Gulf, amid puzzling behavior of the passenger jet. Blaming the victim was standard fare, as reporters focused on the plight of U.S.S. *Vincennes* commander Capt. Will Rodgers III, whose picture appeared on tabloid covers (7/5/88) with bold headlines: “Captain’s Anguish” (Newsday) and “Captain’s Agony” (New York Post).
At the same time, U.S. journalists asserted that the Iranian government was eager to exploit its new propaganda advantage. Correspondent Tom Fenton informed viewers of the CBS Evening News (7/6/88) that Iran was intent on making sure the event would not slip from the world’s front pages; colleague Bert Quint followed up minutes later with a similar theme.
Sorely lacking from the outset was any semblance of soul-searching about the holier-than-Moscow Soviet-bashing that followed the KAL accident. The last thing that White House officials wanted was any such national self-examination. But we might have hoped for more independence from the U.S. media, which allowed their proclaimed precepts to spin 180 degrees in an instant, while discarding basic insights like the one expressed in a New York Times editorial six days after KAL 007 exploded (9/7/83): “To proclaim a ‘right’ to shoot down suspicious planes does not make it right to do so.”
[Extra! July/August 1988](https://fair.org/extra-issues/extra-july-august-1988)
***FAIR’s work is sustained by our generous contributors, who allow us to remain independent. [Donate](https://www.cambeywest.com/EXT/?f=donate) today to be a part of this important mission.***
### Related Posts
- [ABC's Iran Propaganda](https://fair.org/take-action/action-alerts/abcs-iran-propaganda/)
- [NPR's Fresh Air](https://fair.org/extra/nprs-fresh-air/)
- [](https://fair.org/extra/iran-contra-sweep-it-away/)
[Iran/Contra: Sweep It Away](https://fair.org/extra/iran-contra-sweep-it-away/)
- [What's Missing From Time's Iran Timeline](https://fair.org/home/whats-missing-from-times-iran-timeline/)
Filed under: [Extra! 1988 Ed. 4 - July/August](https://fair.org/topic/extra-july-august-1988/), [Iran](https://fair.org/topic/iran/), [New York Times](https://fair.org/topic/new-york-times/), [Russia](https://fair.org/topic/russia/)
#### **[FAIR](https://fair.org/author/woodglue/)**
FAIR, the national media watch group, has been offering well-documented criticism of media bias and censorship since 1986. We work to invigorate the First Amendment by advocating for greater diversity in the press and by scrutinizing media practices that marginalize public interest, minority and dissenting viewpoints.
◄ Previous Post [Nicaragua’s Drug Connection Exposed as Hoax](https://fair.org/extra/nicaraguas-drug-connection-exposed-as-hoax/)
► Next Post [Fear & Loathing at the Democratic Convention](https://fair.org/extra/fear-amp-loathing-at-the-democratic-convention/)
Extra\!
#### What’s FAIR
FAIR is the national progressive media watchdog group, challenging corporate media bias, spin and misinformation. We work to invigorate the First Amendment by advocating for greater diversity in the press and by scrutinizing media practices that marginalize public interest, minority and dissenting viewpoints. We expose neglected news stories and defend working journalists when they are muzzled. As a progressive group, we believe that structural reform is ultimately needed to break up the dominant media conglomerates, establish independent public broadcasting and promote strong non-profit sources of information.
#### Contact
**Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting**
124 W. 30th Street, Suite 201
New York, NY 10001
Tel: 212-633-6700
[Email directory](https://fair.org/contact-fair/)
#### Support
We rely on your support to keep running. Please consider donating.
[DONATE](https://www.cambeywest.com/EXT/?f=donate)
English 
- English
- Deutsch
- Español
- Français
- Italiano
- Polski
- Svenska
- Suomi
- Português
- Română
- Slovenščina
- Slovenčina
- Nederlands
- Dansk
- Ελληνικά
- Čeština
- Magyar
- Lietuvių
- Latviešu
- Eesti
- Hrvatski
- Gaeilge
- Български
- Norsk
- Türkçe
- Bahasa Indonesia
- Português (Brasil)
- 日本語
- 한국어
- 简体中文
- العربية
- Русский
- हिन्दी
- Українська
- Srpski
- England
- ایران
- ישראל
- Македонија
- ประเทศไทย
- Việt Nam
Accessibility Adjustments
Powered by [OneTap](https://wponetap.com/?utm_source=plugin-guru.com&utm_medium=link&utm_campaign=ref-link-toolbar)
Hide Toolbar
Back
How long do you want to hide the toolbar?
Not Now
Hide Toolbar
Select your accessibility profile
Vision Impaired Mode
Enhances website's visuals
Seizure Safe Profile
Clear flashes & reduces color
ADHD Friendly Mode
Focused browsing, distraction-free
Blindness Mode
Reduces distractions, improves focus
Epilepsy Safe Mode
Dims colors and stops blinking
Content Modules
Font Size
\+
Default
\-
Readable Font
Line Height
\+
Default
\-
Cursor
Letter Spacing
Align Text
Font Weight
Color Modules
Light Contrast
High Contrast
Monochrome
Orientation Modules
Reading Line
Reading Mask
Hide Images
Highlight Content
Stop Animations
Highlight Links
Reset Settings
[FAIR](https://fair.org/?blackhole=45db69e495 "Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!")
[](http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/)
This work is licensed under a [Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported](http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/) License. |
| Readable Markdown | null |
| Shard | 26 (laksa) |
| Root Hash | 6180890750244472026 |
| Unparsed URL | org,fair!/extra/kal-007-and-iran-air-655/ s443 |